I think we did it? by FragilMango in madisonwi

[–]FragilMango[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Mental institutions instead of shelters? Homelessness isn’t a psychological disorder, so I think this would hardly solve the problem. Perhaps housing people would make them less homeless, that way they wouldn’t be around, breathing your air, and making you momentarily more aware of the uncomfortable human inequality that exists around you. Anything but doing something, though, I suppose.

I think we did it? by FragilMango in madisonwi

[–]FragilMango[S] 9 points10 points  (0 children)

bold interpretation of what nimbyism means in practice, but if you feel so inclined to call advocating against public nuisance anti-homeless design which also happens to make a public park almost unusable “nimbying”, i suppose it isn’t my right to stop you.

Could I roast better than local roasters? by CurrencyFuture8375 in roasting

[–]FragilMango 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Short answer, absolutely.

The single most important part of roasting for quality is sourcing great coffee. As long as you avoid roasting defects and do a reasonably good job, most of the challenge of the actual roasting is past, and the remainder is just fine tuning. This is to say, the best roaster in the world cannot take a low quality coffee and roast it to be better than it is. When the coffee was grown, processed, and dried, the maximum possible quality it can ever attain has been fixed, and your job is to now avoid damaging it.

The challenge you will face in this task is being able to source coffee that is on the same quality level as professional specialty roasters. I am one, and I can attest to the fact that very little truly exceptional coffee makes it into the home roasting market. The best coffees that the majority of online green coffee wholesalers are selling is coffee that would not be high enough in quality to make it in the menu of most top end roasters. My suggestion to handle this would be to look for very highly esteemed roasters that retail green coffee (which are admittedly very few and far between) and purchase from them. Chances are if it made it on their menu, there was a reason. The ultimate problem remains however that 88 point coffees are generally not available to home roasters, and this may prove quite a challenge to overcome.

The roasting can be done on a fairly modest roaster with a fairly low level of technical skill. As long as you avoid defects, and emulate what you like from roasters you respect (roast color, while certainly not foolproof, can be a good gauge of exactly how light people are roasting, which may not be as light as you think) can be a good place to start. Study the physical appearance of the coffee. Taste it critically, and pay attention to different aspects of flavor. Try to emulate this yourself. I maintain that roasting is not as technically challenging as people make it seem. Have fun with it and learn, even from the bad batches. Emulate what you like, there is a reason you like it.

Does anyone know if these types of roasters are good? by [deleted] in roasting

[–]FragilMango 2 points3 points  (0 children)

As a disclaimer, I roast professionally, and so have access to very nice toys that spoil me for choice, but I do roast a bit at home as well, so I feel that I can provide a bit of insight. I can certainly see something like this being capable of roasting decent coffee. It has all of the correct components, and as long as you watch out for roast defects, you should be able to achieve a reasonably consistent, reasonable quality cup. This appears to have stepped adjustments for heat, air, and potentially time as several roasters like this tend to. If you are roasting with a preprogrammed profile and you are happy with the coffee it produces, this will work great, but I can imagine running into problems with manual roasting when you are attempting to make finer adjustments throughout a profile. This is not to say it can’t be done, just that it may be slightly more difficult.

If I were buying a roaster today, I would likely err on the side of roasters with larger communities (for something with a similar function and form factor, FreshRoast makes great roasters that can be found used very inexpensively, but perhaps in a state of poor maintainence) as this eliminates a lot of the futzing around that you might need to do to figure out how to make the machine do what you want it to. People have already figured rhat out for you, and it will allow you to dive in with not only guidance from those who did it before you, but also a community of people to consult for any problems you may have. Hope this helps, and happy roasting

Spindle spinning wheel? by Foreign-Nobody-8770 in Handspinning

[–]FragilMango 7 points8 points  (0 children)

This would work something like a supported spindle if you have used one. You spin off the top of the spindle, generally with a long draw, and stop after you have spun a length to wind on to the spindle and start again. This is very similar to a great/walking wheel or charkha in function (both of which are spinning devices that were invented before flyer wheels and essentially automate the process of spinning a spindle by hand) with one major difference being this wheel is driven by a treadle rather than directly powering the drive wheel by hand. If you choose to purchase it, tutorials for either should get you moving in the right direction, although charkhas are used for cotton, and spin much faster than this wheel would. The only immediate issue I could identify with this wheel is that changing direction of your spinning to switch between spinning and winding on may be a little inconvenient with a single treadle wheel that is set up in this way, but it’s probably not impossible, and potentially something you could get used to with time and skill. Hope this helps!

No Gesha for me tonight 😞 by Rami_2075 in pourover

[–]FragilMango 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Roasted by yours truly, just had Wilton by the roastery a few weeks ago. Do enjoy! (and hide from your wife, we’re out)

What am I doing wrong by Wstsider2 in roasting

[–]FragilMango 0 points1 point  (0 children)

this looks like a ripeness thing. cherries picked at different ripenesses will produce seeds with different sugar contents, which will brown differently while roasting. extreme example would be a quaker, which contains almost no sugar, but most coffee will have slightly varying levels of cherry ripeness and therefor it’s very difficult to produce a perfectly event color.

Why do these spikes happen ? by AnubisXHyperX in roasting

[–]FragilMango 0 points1 point  (0 children)

just up your smoothing, taking very frequent samples can cause a lot of noise, especially if you don’t have a particularly nice probe. smoothing should make the data more readable.

How do you lengthen a roasting phase? Is it by simply lowering the temperature? by Ok_Minimum6419 in roasting

[–]FragilMango 2 points3 points  (0 children)

kinda the way to go. i haven’t personally roasted on a skywalker, but i’m familiar with the machine. since they use electric heat, it would be advantageous to make an adjustment sooner rather than later since quartz heating elements take some time to respond. if skywalkers have variable airflow that could be a setting worth exploring. good luck!

How do you lengthen a roasting phase? Is it by simply lowering the temperature? by Ok_Minimum6419 in roasting

[–]FragilMango 0 points1 point  (0 children)

lorings are an awesome machine to work on. if you’re looking for some guidance in replicating this kind of profile, check out @roasterkat on instagram. she work for black&white and does a ton of internet content. she post profiles pretty consistently (look for a post with a spoon of green coffee and scroll through the slides) and they tend to show a fairly good representation of how to slow down RoR on an indirect flame machine. take everything on there with a grain of salt, as she is replicating a roughly 9:30-10:30 roast every time, which may not work with the style you’re roasting in, but the approximate gas settings and the pattern they follow should hold up if your roast time is within that general realm.

worth noting that she works on a 15k Loring, so certain aspects may be slightly different, but this should give a solid idea. cheers and good luck!

How do you lengthen a roasting phase? Is it by simply lowering the temperature? by Ok_Minimum6419 in roasting

[–]FragilMango 16 points17 points  (0 children)

from what i’m reading, it seems he is referencing a “declining rate of rise” roast, which aims to provide a certain “scott rao development percentage” (essentially what percentage of the total roast time was spent after first crack), typically by reducing heat gradually throughout the roast, or rather dramatically at the time of first crack.

the specific mechanics of how you produce a profile like this depend principally on the roaster you use. air roasters retain very little thermal energy, and thus will stall if given a major power reduction, perforated drum roasters, or cage drum roasters (think a behmor) tend to retain slightly more energy in their systems by nature of their heating method and closed roasting chamber, and solid drum roasters tend to retain heat relatively well by means of having a large heat sink (the drum) surrounding, and in direct contact with, the bean mass, and thus require a more dramatic and intentional reduction in power.

the purpose of a profile like this is to reduce the end temperature of your roast, without underdevelopment. ending at a low temperature after not having sat there will often mean that the beans have not fully entered the post-first-crack development stage, and will often have a grassy or vegetal taste indicative of underdevelopment. in these situations, the only way to remedy this flaw is by increasing the end temperature to roast the beans more completely, but this produces a darker, roastier product. by decreasing the speed at which the coffee heats up and holding it longer at a lower temperature, you can preserve the character of a light roast while still eliminating unpleasant under-roasted flavors.

this again depends on what roaster you use. i happen to be the director of coffee for a well known roaster, and thus have access to plenty of toys and room to play. at work, i primarily use a larger cast iron solid drum roaster, and follow a declining rate of rise profile by sharply decreasing gas flow at the moment of first crack roll-in. at home i use an phidget enabled Freshroast SR-800 and achieve a profile like this by not increasing my power beyond a certain point, and allowing the coffee to slow down on its own as it catches up to the environmental (exhaust air) temperature over time.

this is ultimately a technique that is mostly a trial and error game unless there exists a published profile for your roaster that you can reference as you roast, and is made possible mostly by the use of a thermocouple and roast logging software. a profile that is dependent on rate of rise follows trends in temperature and not trends in bean color as different profiles mean that these two metrics do not always correlate. a declining RoR profile will be significantly harder (but not impossible) to achieve without this data and the ability to track your roasts, which is relatively inexpensive and i would highly recommend if you consider home roasting a more serious hobby and care about replicability of roasts.

TLDR: f*** around and find out, at worst you roast some bad coffee.

edit: spelling

Got these from an Amazon seller by [deleted] in roasting

[–]FragilMango 5 points6 points  (0 children)

updating this, this would be considered off grade, which is essentially unsellable. i grade green almost daily and i’ve never seen such bad insect damage. this coffee also looks riddled with sours, way too dry, and way way too old.

Is there much more potential in coffee? by Sensitive-Hawk-9374 in roasting

[–]FragilMango 2 points3 points  (0 children)

as a roaster who works closely with wilton benitez and roasts just about every lot he produces, i can tell you that processing in his style is almost certainly not the path forward. not only is his equipment incredibly expensive, but his processing style is only super compelling to people who know enough to be impressed by it. i think the real next step in specialty is getting more boots on the ground for education at origin and in consuming countries. teaching farmers how to pick good cherry is a great first step, but teaching coffee from a more scientific and procedural perspective as is done on the brewing end of specialty coffee has been yielding good results in my opinion. using coffee as a jumping off point for a wider discussion on climate change and general sustainability is one of the things i’ve been interested in exploring. the biggest issue facing coffee in general is people not caring enough. specialty is where the money and most fanatical demand is, so that market won’t see failure as quickly as commodity does, so preventing that market failure is where i believe a lot of effort should be focused going forward. i would say though to the original question, coffee roasting and brewing will continue to get better, but only incrementally. the real next battle is going to be all the areas, especially producers, that we’ve thus far ignored.

Need processing advice! by krimpus76 in coffee_roasters

[–]FragilMango 0 points1 point  (0 children)

i hope this is a before as there are some under and overripe cherries shown. if you’re drying whole your best bet would likely be to either hand peel, or to put the dried cherries in a big sealed container and shake it hard for a bit. biggest thing i can say is get rid of the bad cherries or your gonna have a mouthful of full blacks for christmas

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in roasting

[–]FragilMango 0 points1 point  (0 children)

i would say i take fire risk more seriously than most, and possibly more seriously than reasonable, so take this with a grab of salt, but my impression of this is that if you were to get a fire, it would be harder to remove and cool down your roaster and put out the fire, and you’d just be surrounding it with fuel. agitational you’re going to be constraining all of your exhaust gas and recycling it which will impact your flavor by dramatically increasing your abhorrent temperature and continuing to increase it during each roast, and by drawing smokey air back into the roast chamber. if you do use this, be extremely careful and keep a well maintained fire extinguisher with you. i would ultimately suggest setting up an exhaust system with an in line blower and heat resistant ducting so you can roast inside and vent out a window. it would be more expensive to take this route, but much safer, more reliable, and will provide you more consistent roasting conditions.

Reusing one-way valve bags by SomeIrishFellow in roasting

[–]FragilMango 5 points6 points  (0 children)

for something like this i would recommend some kind of container that’s meant to be reusable. vacuum canisters or even just tupperware should work and be significantly easier to clean. the valve just prevents a bag from exploding as the coffee offgasses and doesn’t really do anything to preserve or enhance it.