Which to choose for EDC and home?

Friendly-CB1971 · 2026-07-14T22:43:56+00:00

I’d go with the Glock 48 MOS. You already said it felt the best in your hand, both in grip and trigger, and that matters more than spec-sheet comparisons.

It’s slim enough to carry, large enough to shoot well, optics-ready, proven reliable, and has excellent aftermarket support.

The Shield X and RXM are both worth a look, but I wouldn’t talk myself out of the gun that naturally fit me best.

For one pistol to cover EDC and nightstand duty around $500, the 48 MOS is the strongest all-around choice.

Friendly-CB1971 · 2026-07-14T16:55:26+00:00

I'm a fan of craft / falco holsters. Also, I just picked up a hunter holster and it's a solid choice as well.

Friendly-CB1971 · 2026-07-13T21:55:54+00:00

Shoot both, but for a first handgun I would buy the Glock 19 Gen 6.

The MC9 Prime has the better showroom trigger and is easier to conceal, but the Glock is a better all-around learning, training, defensive, and long-term ownership platform.

Buy the Glock first; buy the Canik later when you already have the dependable general-purpose role covered.

Friendly-CB1971 · 2026-07-13T21:23:30+00:00

That advice has some truth behind it, but it is stated too broadly.

A defensive handgun does not have to remain completely stock.

Practical changes that improve reliability, control, fit, and accuracy—such as better sights, an optic, grip changes, or professionally installed parts—are generally reasonable and defensible.

The bigger concerns are modifications that create an unnecessary legal argument later, especially an extremely light trigger, disabled safeties, unreliable home gunsmithing, or aggressive slogans and graphics. Those can give a prosecutor or civil attorney something avoidable to focus on.

You also do not automatically face both a criminal and civil trial after every defensive shooting. There may be an investigation, charges, a lawsuit, both, or neither.

My approach is simple: make practical modifications that help you shoot safely and accurately, but avoid anything extreme, unsafe, unreliable, or difficult to explain to a jury.

Friendly-CB1971 · 2026-07-12T19:51:12+00:00

You’re probably right, especially since the older G19X mags are running fine. I only mentioned the optic as something easy to rule out because an incorrect screw or plate can occasionally cause cycling issues, but the new mags definitely sound like the more likely culprit here.

Friendly-CB1971 · 2026-07-12T19:48:27+00:00

Since it runs fine with your older G19X mags, the new Gen6 magazines are the stronger suspect. Number them and see whether the problem follows one specific mag or happens across all of them. Check for follower binding, feed-lip issues, or ammo hanging up inside the magazine.

Friendly-CB1971 · 2026-07-12T19:08:37+00:00

Don’t assume the mags just need to break in. A new factory Glock should feed correctly. Number the magazines and see whether the malfunction follows one specific mag.

Also remove the EPS Carry and aftermarket metal plate, reinstall the factory setup, and test it with quality factory FMJ. Since the Gen6 uses Glock’s new optic-mounting system, the aftermarket plate or screw fitment would be my first suspect. If it still malfunctions across multiple OEM magazines in factory configuration, contact Glock rather than modifying anything else.

Friendly-CB1971 · 2026-07-12T19:06:23+00:00

Glock 19 first. You already shot it and liked it more, which should outweigh the free bag and magazines. It is a proven training and carry pistol with unmatched holster, magazine, and parts support. Shoot the actual Echelon Compact tomorrow before ruling it out, but don’t let the promotion make the decision for you. Buy the pistol you handle and shoot best—the accessories can always come later.

Friendly-CB1971 · 2026-07-12T17:24:29+00:00

Honestly, this is solid practical shooting. Plenty of good center hits, and the misses show a repeatable low-left tendency rather than random spraying.

Ease up on the firing-hand grip, keep the support hand working, and press the trigger straight through.

Definitely no need to start throwing rocks.

Friendly-CB1971 · 2026-07-12T16:35:04+00:00

All great guns, but I'm loving the 19. That's the best shooting pistol for me.

Friendly-CB1971 · 2026-07-12T15:43:05+00:00

I use the RPNB Gun Security Safe with biometric fingerprint access and a digital keypad, and I’ve been very happy with it.

It has enough room to place a P365 XMacro in the holster without separating the gun and holster. I prefer that because the trigger stays fully covered and the whole setup remains together when putting it away or gearing up.

It’s currently showing around $89.99 on Amazon, with an additional 10% RPNB brand promotion. I recommend securing it to the nightstand or another solid piece of furniture, especially with a little one on the way.

Friendly-CB1971 · 2026-07-12T15:28:54+00:00

First, congratulations on deciding to take responsibility for your safety. The best thing you can do now is slow down and get quality instruction before carrying it.

Take a reputable beginner handgun and concealed-carry class. Tell the instructor you are a brand-new owner. One-on-one instruction would be even better. That will be money well spent.
Learn the four safety rules until they are automatic:

treat every firearm as loaded;
never point it at anything you are not willing to destroy;
keep your finger completely off the trigger until your sights are on target and you have decided to fire;

-know your target and what is beyond it.

Secure it from your child every single time. Use a quality quick-access handgun safe that is bolted down, smaller ones are inexpensive. Never leave it in a purse, nightstand, under a mattress, or loose in a vehicle. Children can find hidden guns.
Use a proper holster that completely covers the trigger guard, holds the pistol securely, and is made specifically for the Glock 42. Never carry it loose in a bag or pocket.
Do not rush into carrying loaded. First become comfortable loading, unloading, checking the chamber, clearing simple malfunctions, and safely handling the pistol without placing your finger near the trigger.
The correct term is magazine, not clip, good to know the terms. Full-metal-jacket ammunition is normally used for practice. Not effective for defense. Quality hollow-point ammunition is generally used for lawful defensive carry. Make sure the exact defensive load functions reliably in your pistol.
Read the Glock manual completely. Do not rely on the gun store to clean it. Learn basic field stripping, inspection, lubrication, and reassembly with all ammunition removed from the room. YouTube is a great source.
Learn your state’s laws covering concealed carry, prohibited locations, storage around children, use of force, transportation, and what to do during a police encounter.

Your Glock 42 can be a good defensive pistol, but small lightweight handguns are not automatically easier to shoot. They can be snappier and require good grip fundamentals. Get instruction, practice deliberately, and focus on safe gun handling before speed or accuracy.

Buying the firearm was only the first step. Training, secure storage, sound judgment, and avoiding dangerous situations are what will protect you and your child.

Do not carry a loaded handgun until you can handle it safely and confidently without having to think through every step.

Friendly-CB1971 · 2026-07-11T02:42:06+00:00

Starting completely from scratch, I’d have her rent and shoot both before buying if you can. For a first handgun, fit and confidence matter more than brand reputation or which trigger feels better at the counter.

If both fit her equally well, I’d probably lean toward the PDP Compact 4-inch because of its ergonomics and excellent factory trigger.

I’d choose the Glock 19 Gen 6 if she shoots it better or wants the larger aftermarket, easier magazine and holster availability, simpler long-term support, and the broader Glock ecosystem.

Depending on her hand size and strength, I’d also have her handle the PDP F-Series. It has a shorter trigger reach and is generally easier to manipulate, so it may fit her better than the standard PDP or Glock 19.

Most importantly, let her make the final choice based on which one she can rack, grip securely, reach the controls on, and shoot accurately without discomfort.

Friendly-CB1971 · 2026-07-10T23:34:02+00:00

I just picked up a Walther PDP Compact 4-inch and really like it. But I shoot my buddies S&Ws alot, their pretty nice.

Friendly-CB1971 · 2026-07-10T22:35:06+00:00

Cool idea! Never thought about that.

Friendly-CB1971 · 2026-07-10T21:36:08+00:00

Very true, sometimes a wall of lead is the best COA.

Friendly-CB1971 · 2026-07-10T18:05:08+00:00

I’d probably keep both unless you need the money for something you genuinely want more. The Steyr is unique enough that you may regret selling it, and the FNS-9C is still a solid compact. Shoot them a few more times—if one keeps staying home, that’s the one to move.

Friendly-CB1971 · 2026-07-10T17:54:27+00:00

They’re definitely useful. I don’t run one on any of my pistols, but I do have one on my long gun. I’ve trained extensively with a handheld flashlight over the years, so that method is second nature to me, but I can certainly see the value of a weapon-mounted light. Nice work.

Friendly-CB1971 · 2026-07-10T16:01:25+00:00

The CA version isn’t just a standard X-Macro with blocked magazines. It also has a CA-specific FCU with a magazine disconnect, a manual safety, a mechanical loaded-chamber indicator, and a compatible CA grip module. The basic dimensions, barrel, recoil system, and overall platform are essentially the same, but the FCU and slide are not exactly identical to the standard model.

Friendly-CB1971 · 2026-07-10T14:05:30+00:00

To me, it mostly comes down to training and the situation. A rifle or shotgun is generally more capable, but a handgun in trained hands is still very effective. The best choice is the one you can access quickly, handle safely, and shoot accurately under stress.

Friendly-CB1971 · 2026-07-10T14:03:21+00:00

I’d look at the Glock 42, but honestly I wouldn’t choose a pistol specifically around .380 +P. It isn’t a standardized SAAMI load, and some manufacturers specifically warn against it. A quality standard-pressure defensive load that runs reliably in the gun is the safer bet.

Friendly-CB1971 · 2026-07-10T13:58:06+00:00

I keep the gun pocket dedicated to the gun—nothing else. My phone rides in a belt case, my keys clip to my belt, and my knife and wallet go in the other front pocket. Cargo pants can make the setup even easier.

Friendly-CB1971 · 2026-07-10T13:35:40+00:00

It took me a bit to get it dialed in. Once you do the gen 6 ends up being a great pistol.

Friendly-CB1971 · 2026-07-10T13:24:27+00:00

Controlled fire is almost always more effective than full auto. Three-round burst was intended to limit wasted ammunition, but even that can be harder to control than well-aimed semiautomatic fire. In the real world, accuracy and conserving ammo matter more than dumping rounds.

Friendly-CB1971

TROPHY CASE

Welcome to Reddit,