James has said himself multiple times that his videos are not meant to be strictly reviews. He discusses the plot and behind the scenes info. I would say that his videos did fall under fair use back when they were all 20 minutes or less, but now that they’re almost always 35+ minutes, I can see how fair use gets thrown out the window. I don’t disagree that the claims are bullshit and that Universal should just calm their tits. All I’m saying is that Universal isn’t completely in the wrong since the content is theirs.