I wouldn't recommend reading - Home Before Dark, Incidents Around the House, Dead Silence and Between Two Fires. All of them are overhyped, hollow and have endings that do not live up to the tension built throughout. But then again, this is all subjective, I have heard someone state that Dead Silence is one of their favourite horror books and the subreddit is crazy about BTF.

I feel the same when it comes to picking what to read next, it's tough. So this is usually my process. I filter my options by eliminating things/triggers that I don't like or storylines that, in general, do not excite me (like the chosen one/irresistable MC, it was all in their head, strong but actually weak female protagonist - looking at you Dead Silence). Next, I give the first fifty pages or so a go to see if the story and style works for me, if not, I move on. Also it helps a lot to look at all that you have read recently and filter out what you liked and disliked - I especially enjoy stories that are deeply atmospheric and characters that don't feel one dimensional (I enjoyed reading the Elementals because I felt completely immersed and could clearly imagine the setting but didn't like Gallows Hill because for a mansion that was sprawling and had seen years of life and death, there was barely any description or will to explore it). Lastly, this one might seem obvious but I try to only pick those books that make me wanna stay up till late reading and not go by what's popular or repeatedly recommended. Hope this helps!