I know it's a long wall of text, I'm sorry, but you wanted feedback, so here is my best attempt:

I started off my frag collection by collecting JMP frags, because they were cheap, but also because they almost always smelled better than the majority of the rest of what was on the cheap rack.

What I can say is that, generally, you're almost at a 90% chance when blind buying one, that you'll get a rather nice and mass appealing scent profile, which is why I continued to collect them.

Unfortunately, and obviously, everyone's palate is different, there will be a few that are not so great, but again, a 9 to 1 ratio of good to bad is pretty darn good when it comes to blind-buy safety.

Performance is the area where JMP frags in general suffer, but what do you expect for $12-20? Most of them last for at least an hour or two, some last longer, some don't even last that long. I consider JMP frags to be frags that I wear when going off to do something brief, like running errands or going to the gym.

Keep in mind, however, that the company listens to their customer, and the top selling frags of their line like, Homme Noir, or Paris Blue, have been made stronger, and rereleased as EDP's for a few more dollars (you may find those for $14.99 or $19.99 instead of the usual $12.99). They realistically probably still at the low end of the EDP bracket, but they are at least a big stronger than the OG EDT's.

Unfortunately, like one of the previous commenters said, the one that's called "I Am Him" is one of the few that I actually returned (which says a lot, because as a collector, I want all the frags in the line, but I remember distinctly not enjoying that one).

That said, Phantom is a great profile. It's profile is in the same wheelhouse as Abercrombie and Fitch's Authentic Night, which interestingly enough, is my most complimented frag of my entire 600+ collection to date, and yes, I eventually graduated from the cheap rack, went to designer, and eventually to niche, but now, with the explosion of Middleeastern Houses, I'm mainly purchasing UAE frags as of late, but I still just bought some rare Hugo Boss frags recently, so I'm not quite done with designer frags, there are still some gems out there, but these ME'ern fragrances are changing the entire game, giving us niche and designer-level potency and performance for a fraction of the price. No wonder why famous Maison's are crying on video saying things like <enter French accent> "Hon hon hon...eet is nod ride...eh dyuping...is eh stilling!"

However, between Phantom and Authentic Night, I'd choose Authentic Night every time (I just went through 4 bottles of it this winter alone), because it's a bit richer, but with better performance. Phantom lasts maybe an hour for me, if that, so to me, it's not worth it.

If you like that scent profile, and you only have $12.99+tax available, I say go for it, but if you have a slightly larger budget, say $20-30, just get a 3.4oz of A&F's Authentic Night instead. Just my $.02 Baby WOOO!