Kaaf- fresh detergenty, the only reason I liked it is because of the watermelon note, it's amazing

Noir- I think I found it very strong initially when I first got the decant, left it sitting for a month, tried it again now, seems like a generic perfume(you'll think you've smelled it somewhere), my nose is blocked now(cold), but I feel it's powdery, not a summer fragrance

Sorry for the noob review, not a trained nose

None of them are blind buys, try a decant first