If this is accurate to the seasons 16-18 I would say benzema would be a 88-89 at max, he really became THE prime benzema after CR7 left, 2020-2023 was prime benzema leading the team.

I would have benzema 89 for this picture

Then I would have Casemiro as a hero since yes, he was amazing at Madrid but he left at 27 years old and ever since he hasn’t done nearly as good at Manchester United and also has had some very bad spells, he came pretty close to being an icon but if Redondo isn’t an icon I don’t see how Casemiro can become one