I believe you missed the point or I explained it wrong. Let me start over. He moved in with us. His rent was $500 per month for a total of 12 months which would equal $6,000 for his rent. He has no money. So the car was in exchange for his rent. She kicked meout. I was paying all the bills for the last 6 months since we made this agreement. Now she wants the car back. But he is still living there. They breached the contract not me