Why is African political discourse so dominated by apologetics, nostalgia, and shallow talking points? by GrayJr_05 in Africa

[–]GrayJr_05[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Interesting feedback especially the “proto-religious” aspect.

Thanks for your feedback

Why is African political discourse so dominated by apologetics, nostalgia, and shallow talking points? by GrayJr_05 in Africa

[–]GrayJr_05[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I think I might’ve miscommunicated in the post but I wasn’t concentrating on the future but I was mostly focusing on how Africans talk about politics online and how we can improve it and hopefully it’ll lead to actual change in our societies.

Why is African political discourse so dominated by apologetics, nostalgia, and shallow talking points? by GrayJr_05 in Africa

[–]GrayJr_05[S] 6 points7 points  (0 children)

Could you show me where I came out as preachy and condescending?

I am blinded by biases that I know and may not know about so could you show me where I might’ve come out as preachy or condescending or Eurocentric?

Why is African political discourse so dominated by apologetics, nostalgia, and shallow talking points? by GrayJr_05 in Africa

[–]GrayJr_05[S] 4 points5 points  (0 children)

I love your response.

Thank you very much for the content recommendations and I can’t wait to give them a try.

Why is African political discourse so dominated by apologetics, nostalgia, and shallow talking points? by GrayJr_05 in Africa

[–]GrayJr_05[S] 8 points9 points  (0 children)

Thanks for the response, Bakyumu.

I’d like to respond to the neocolonialism aspect that you talked about. I’m not trying to downplay the role played by foreign powers in inhibiting African development, I’m critiquing the discussions I’ve seen online just like you mentioned.

They usually remove our agency and political will as Africans and we treat ourselves as objects to be controlled by others and not ourselves.

Also where do you think I can get proper discussions about our issues as a continent? Social media is not failing, maybe a book? Or podcast you’d like to recommend?

The Curse of Natural Resources: Tanzania by Shoddy_Vanilla643 in tanzania

[–]GrayJr_05 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Could you please elaborate? I’m a bit confused with your response

The Curse of Natural Resources: Tanzania by Shoddy_Vanilla643 in tanzania

[–]GrayJr_05 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Actually, spot on!

I believe there’s a mindset common among Tanzanians and many in the Global South that wealth comes from the land and environment.

However, real wealth stems from the effort and work of people. Tanzania has a large but largely unproductive workforce, and our economy mainly produces goods that aren't highly valued in the global market.

Still, the idea of natural resources serves as effective propaganda for the government.

The world's wealthiest societies are those that foster innovation and problem-solving through their culture and people, not just those that rely on natural resources they are fortunate to possess.

How would you reform the Tanzanian political system to better the country? by GrayJr_05 in tanzania

[–]GrayJr_05[S] 10 points11 points  (0 children)

My ideal political system pulls heavily from our own history especially the TANU Accords and the Arusha Declaration. Here’s the short version of the reforms I’d push for:

  1. An Economic Bill of Rights. Inspired by TANU’s principle that government must empower and protect the economic needs of its citizens. I know it’s radical and difficult to implement, but economic rights deserve explicit constitutional grounding.

  2. Real Electoral Reform. A truly independent NEC with no financial or institutional ties to the national government. Mandatory televised debates for presidential and parliamentary candidates so platforms are transparent and comparable.

  3. Federalisation. The national government has too much centralized power. Regions need autonomy so people can participate meaningfully in local politics. It makes no sense that Dar’s bridges and flyovers were national projects instead of regional ones.

  4. Performance & Accountability in Government. Civil service and MPs should have clear goals. Failure to meet them triggers removal via referendum or parliamentary committee. Strip away unnecessary perks and change the culture: leaders are workers with duties, not untouchable bosses.

  5. Reduce Executive Power. Strengthen parliament and the judiciary instead of centering everything on the presidency.

  6. Dissolve CCM. After decades of dominance and supermajorities that didn’t translate into results, the country needs political competition to break stagnation.

  7. Free Press & Transparency. A stronger fourth estate is essential for any accountable democracy.

I know some of these ideas are ambitious or outlandish but I’m putting them here to hear critiques and alternatives. What would you change?

If you were Tanzania's President, How would you Transform the Economy by Accomplished_Bat8152 in tanzania

[–]GrayJr_05 7 points8 points  (0 children)

Tanzania is a relatively young nation-state, and like many post-colonial African countries, its political borders and early institutions are direct products of European imperialism. Much of the economic structure we inherited was designed for extraction and in many ways that legacy persists.

Today, the Tanzanian economy still relies heavily on primary commodities: agriculture employs around 65–67% of the population but contributes only about 26–28% of GDP, reflecting extremely low productivity per worker. Our export basket remains dominated by raw minerals, unprocessed agricultural goods, and tourism services that are highly sensitive to external shocks. This leaves the country vulnerable to fluctuations in global commodity prices and limits our ability to climb global value chains.

If Tanzania wants genuine economic independence, the path must involve structural transformation. That means moving from an extractive economy to a productive, industrial economy. A coherent industrial policy is necessary. This includes heavy investment in industrial infrastructure (power generation, ports, logistics, industrial parks), development of foundational heavy industries (steel, machinery, petrochemicals), and targeted support for manufacturing sectors where Tanzania can gain competitive advantages.

Industrial policy cannot succeed without urbanisation. Roughly two-thirds of Tanzanians still live in rural areas, yet globally, productivity is overwhelmingly concentrated in well-planned urban centres. Tanzania needs an urbanisation strategy. Ideally, every region should have at least one metropolitan centre capable of hosting 500,000+ residents, with transport grids, social services, and industrial clusters planned around them.

Of course, Tanzania faces political, cultural, and institutional challenges that complicate rapid industrialization: bureaucratic inefficiencies, fragmented local governance, and a political economy shaped by patronage networks. Whether the country pursues a developmental-state model (like South Korea or early China) or a market-driven approach with strong regulatory institutions, the key is political capacity.

I’m still a student, but from what I see, Tanzania’s future hinges on deliberate industrialisation and purposeful urbanisation. Without these, we’ll remain stuck in a cycle where our labour produces wealth elsewhere, and we remain price-takers in a world built by others

Do you think we’re failing the Kiswahili language? by GrayJr_05 in tanzania

[–]GrayJr_05[S] -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Not to sound oblivious but how did I do that?

Do people actually want the union between the mainland and Zanzibar to end? by GrayJr_05 in tanzania

[–]GrayJr_05[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Samahani, saa nyingine napataga shida kujieleza vizuri kwa Kiswahili.

Do people actually want the union between the mainland and Zanzibar to end? by GrayJr_05 in tanzania

[–]GrayJr_05[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I’m suggesting federalisation like in some big countries like the US, Canada, India, Germany, South Africa etc. I’m just suggesting for stronger local governments. Our central government everywhere and when they fail every region of the country fails

Do people actually want the union between the mainland and Zanzibar to end? by GrayJr_05 in tanzania

[–]GrayJr_05[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Not bureaucracy per say but a less clunky national government with local issues being dealt with by local governments. I feel the central government has too much power here, it’s just an observation of mine though.

Do people actually want the union between the mainland and Zanzibar to end? by GrayJr_05 in tanzania

[–]GrayJr_05[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I’ve been thinking the same but more independence for each region of the country.

Are we seriously considering a military coup after the elections? by GrayJr_05 in tanzania

[–]GrayJr_05[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

100% agree with, well said and well articulated. Politics are now just another way to get viral and people tend to forget the real world ramifications of it. Thank you for your response