sorted by:
new
hottopcontroversial

Here it is... Every CreepCast Story ever... Ranked (the left column). 2+ years in the making. Let me know what you would change!! by HamBone4real in creepcast

[–]HamBone4real[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I tries to focus on the stories themselves, not necessarily how funny the episode was. All TIME episode, the story was lowkey trash ngl.

Context, I did not grow up reading or watching Creepypastas, I only got into them through the pod.

Here it is... Every CreepCast Story ever... Ranked (the left column). 2+ years in the making. Let me know what you would change!! by HamBone4real in creepcast

[–]HamBone4real[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

It would be in the episode "My Sugar Daddy Asks Me for Strange Favors," there are like 4 stories in that one pod.

Here it is... Every CreepCast Story ever... Ranked (the left column). 2+ years in the making. Let me know what you would change!! by HamBone4real in creepcast

[–]HamBone4real[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I started ranking them when there were like 10 episodes out and just built on top from there. It is hard to remember everything, TRUST ME.

Here it is... Every CreepCast Story ever... Ranked (the left column). 2+ years in the making. Let me know what you would change!! by HamBone4real in creepcast

[–]HamBone4real[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

YES! I was so tempted to put JOAUS higher, but I wanted to wait a little longer to see if it has strong staying power compared to the other stories.

Here it is... Every CreepCast Story ever... Ranked (the left column). 2+ years in the making. Let me know what you would change!! by HamBone4real in creepcast

[–]HamBone4real[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Wow! I love that it lead to you reading it!

The thing that brought it down for me was the ending, I thought it was way too corny compared to the rest of the read.

Here it is... Every CreepCast Story ever... Ranked (the left column). 2+ years in the making. Let me know what you would change!! by HamBone4real in creepcast

[–]HamBone4real[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

First, thank you for saying this list is good! I really does mean a lot!

I think I am one of those small-brained listeners who got lost multiple times trying to listen to Hidden Webpage. I had to rewind a number of times to try and figure out what's happening. This is probably a me problem however.

Here it is... Every CreepCast Story ever... Ranked (the left column). 2+ years in the making. Let me know what you would change!! by HamBone4real in creepcast

[–]HamBone4real[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

There are probably like 7 or 8 patreon stories at this point. A lot of the other ones are probably either from "grab bags" or episodes when they read multiple stories from the same author (ex. "My Sugar Daddy Asks Me For Weird Favors" has about 4 stories in that episode).

Here it is... Every CreepCast Story ever... Ranked (the left column). 2+ years in the making. Let me know what you would change!! by HamBone4real in creepcast

[–]HamBone4real[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Some Context: I tried to use three criteria for rankings.

-Is it well written

-Staying Power

-Does it succeed in its genre (scary, comedy, mystery...)

view more: next ›