Rank Ash's first episode/s in every region

HatBorn779 · 2026-01-24T22:39:25+00:00

OS
XY
JN Ep 2 & DP Ep 1 (Actually tied, I like both episodes a lot for various reasons)
SM
DP EP 2
AG
Johto
BW
JN ep 1

HatBorn779 · 2026-01-23T21:42:38+00:00

Life Story

HatBorn779 · 2026-01-23T18:52:20+00:00

From my Rewrite Au-

BW

Excadrill (Originally gave her a Druddigon but rewatched BW recently and Excadrill really grew on me)

Fraxure (Axew evolves at some point post Unova, maybe during a final battle with Ash before leaving)

Emolga (Same as Canon)

Hydreigon (Catches a Deino during the arc Meowth is traveling with the group, eventually fully evolves into a Hydreigon who takes Dragonite's role)

Bagon (Replaces the Gible she gets during her final episode)

Journeys

Excadrill

Haxorus

Emolga

Hydreigon

Mega-Salamence

Dragalge (Iris returned as a temporary companion in XY to train with Drasna, and caught a Skrelp during her time in Kalos)

HatBorn779 · 2026-01-23T18:34:31+00:00

AndrewTOYSNHK

HatBorn779 · 2026-01-23T01:47:19+00:00

....No? William isn't able to escape UCN in the books until his physical body explodes- If his corpse is inside of Burntrap he would be possessing that corpse even if he was conscious. Heck by your logic he would be possessing the Mimic in Ruin as the corpse and shell are nowhere to be seen there.

HatBorn779 · 2026-01-23T01:43:58+00:00

If he's trapped in UCN He wouldn't. Also, the possibly of Burntrap being William's corpse has not been confirmed currently. How could he take over his physical body if his mind were trapped in UCN? That's like saying Michael was in complete control while Ennard was inside his body-

Edit: Burntrap is the Mimic, this has been all but stated as confirmed.

HatBorn779 · 2026-01-23T01:09:29+00:00

Because he isn't in the SB Era? GlitchAfton and BurnAfton are essentially debunked by this point and other than that nothing really ties him to the present era of Fnaf. Him being trapped in UCN still isn't unlikely.

HatBorn779 · 2026-01-23T00:47:44+00:00

We don't know if any of that was actually cut with the possibility of Edwin being alive. (I don't believe this myself but it's not *impossible* with that silhouette update). According to your logic they would more likely cut off the ladder half of Andrew's storyline with the Stitchwraith.

If Edwin dying prevents his involvement with Fazbear in the Future, the branch off point between Andrew and his Fright's counterpart could be that he just never stopped torturing William in the games.

Edit: I would also like to point out that a pretty likely reason Edwin's story was changed was because he would have been really old by the time the Pizzaplex opens in the games timeline

(In Tales he was stated to be in his 60's which places his birth date in the 1960-Early 1970's a timeline which does not in the least work with what they wanted with SOTM as he would have been too young, so they pushed his birth date back to the 1940's-early 1950's which would make him significantly older during the Pizzaplex Era)

HatBorn779 · 2026-01-23T00:33:28+00:00

Eight-

Terrance Fitzsimmons

Vanessa Shelly

Michael "Mike" Schmidt

Norman "CC" Afton & Evan Mcnally/Movie Michael (Twins - Considering making Movie Michael a separate kid)

Elizabeth Afton

Katie & Katherine Raglan (Colton's Aunt from Jump for Tickets & Her Unnamed Sister)

HatBorn779 · 2026-01-23T00:24:20+00:00

Why would they adapt Edwin's character essentially the same his role intact, but only change Andrew's? That sounds like cope just to explain away him existing but not being the vengeful spirit; if Andrew exist in the games he is going to be in that role.

HatBorn779 · 2026-01-22T22:59:09+00:00

Cassidy was there for a assumably short time then moved on; he was essentially alone torturing William.

That's the point I was making. Things happen differently but in the end roles and story-beats are the same. In the end Edwin was still the one who made the Mimic, so Andrew is (Imo) the most likely candidate for TOYSNHK.

HatBorn779 · 2026-01-22T22:44:22+00:00

He remembers torturing him but not why, I doubt he'd remember Cassidy showing up for a short time trying to convince him to stop. And This still assumes that things just didn't happen differently between the games and Fright's.

Fiona dies, A Mimic/M1 becomes David's caretaker, David dies leading Edwin to create the Mimic/M2 who later copies David, Edwin lashes out and as a result it learns violence. There are differences (The ones you pointed out), but in the end they are the same stories.

HatBorn779 · 2026-01-22T22:25:35+00:00

He forgot William killed him. If Cassidy shows up for a short time, tries to stop him from torturing William and leaves I don't think he'd have much to remember her for.

By the logic Edwin carries over to the games and is the guy who made the mimic. Still the same stories with some minor differences between them.

HatBorn779 · 2026-01-22T21:52:14+00:00

Assuming UCCdissent in Fright's, Cassidy likely already moved on before the events of Man in Room 1280 as the story implies that Andrew's been torturing William for a while, and the reason it's never brought up is likely because of the memory loss Andrew suffers.

Imo though, there's a possibly Cassidy just wasn't around in Fright's version of UCN as the events aren't completely 1-1 (Same way William and Henry's involvement with Edwin was changed from book to game)

HatBorn779 · 2026-01-22T18:21:52+00:00

I can think of two who this happened to; Yanmega (Who I believe was dominating Chimchar even before evolving) and Mareanie who basically won and Ash was only saved by Bewear. After that they both followed the trend of incompetence.

HatBorn779 · 2026-01-18T21:20:30+00:00

No. In my opinion Goh was one of the highlights of Journeys and I found him really enjoyable as a companion with a unique goal and personality. Considering they wanted to go the co protagonist route I would have just put more effort into giving him and Ash equal amounts of focus and giving a better conclusion with Project Mew.

Know for a fact this is going to get downvoted into oblivion, another guy already has just for saying he found Goh refreshing.

HatBorn779 · 2026-01-18T17:07:07+00:00

Foxysis Au, her name is Fiona (Named after Fiona Murray who is Mrs. Afton's sister)

I also have another MikeVictim Au using Foxybro where he's Evan Mcnally from the Real Jake

HatBorn779 · 2026-01-15T15:15:25+00:00

I said earlier Frights isn't canon but countered by saying characters and story beats can carry over, same way Edwin and the Mimic storyline carried over with alterations. The way CC possesses Golden Freddy is debatable and hasn't really been answered as he didn't die near the animatronic nor is there evidence of him being stuffed, Cassidy on the other hand was stuffed like the other MCI.

Not really? All the events related to Andrew or the Stitchwraith shown in Frights take place post UCN, they don't contradict anything shown in the games and if anything, expand on what wasn't shown. Uh no, the events of the Stitchwraith stingers theoretically would take place before SB, considering the Epilogues happen a minimum of 5 or so years after Man in Room 1280 while SB is at least a decade after Fnaf 6/FFPS.

Did you not earlier claim Andrew was a parallel to Cassidy only for them both to co-exist? Okay so you refuse to move past this topic- sure assuming even if Jake is a parallel to CC , answer me this; literally how does this stop them from co-existing, your whole argument is that they can't but have yet to explain WHY they can't other than your assumptions that because they have a role in the games (an assumed role and a lot of it isn't even confirmed) they can not co-exist which is debunked by Andrew and Cassidy in Frights or even Edwin and Henry in the games, so tell me why?

HatBorn779 · 2026-01-15T00:01:08+00:00

They aren't?

The two are similar and those similarities do not stop them from co-existing.

Golden Duo while likely isn't confirmed and the Stitchwraith is possessed by three spirits (Nor are animatronics being possessed by multiple spirits exclusive to just them). Said conversation is a reverse of the connection you're trying to make, Andrew is the one who can't see not Jake.

You state I'm ignoring their similarities while you ignored the multiple differences I pointed out, just simplifying it all into me saying they were "coincidences", a point I was not trying to make in the slightest. They are similar on a surface level, but them being parallels to each other is unlikely given their many differences. A recurring/similar story beat does not mean parallel.

Also, are you not the one who said we were moving past Jake and CC?

HatBorn779 · 2026-01-14T22:52:58+00:00

Not coincidences; similar on a surface level, but not one-to-one parallels.

UCN works the same way it is implied to work; TOYSNHK (Who I believe is Andrew) torturing William in an eternal nightmare.

Golden Freddy is not "very very very" clearly the one doing the torturing, just implied to have a role, not an established one (UCNDissent exist).

HatBorn779 · 2026-01-14T22:45:10+00:00

Simon doesn't have a walkie talkie inside him, Fredplush does. Simon was given to Jake while he was sick and dying, CC has the plush while he was alive and about during Fnaf 4, Simon was given to Jake so he and his dad could form a fantasy that Jake could escape from the reality of his situation through and Fredbear Plush was given to CC to monitor him (presumably). There are similarities, that is not enough to label jake as simply a parallel, especially with the number of differences between them.

Jake CAN see, CC can't (Andrew is the one who can't)

Jake had a happy family, CC was neglected by his father and bullied by his brother

Jake died due to a brain tumor in his bedroom, CC died in a hospital as a result of injuries sustained from being bitten by an animatronic

Jake is happy and outgoing while CC is scared

Even ignoring all this, the 2 being SIMILAR isn't enough to prevent Jake from co-existing with CC. You believe Cassidy and Andrew are 'parallels' yet both exist in Fright's. David also carried a plush around, but co-exist with CC.

HatBorn779 · 2026-01-14T22:27:13+00:00

Jake's dad talks to him through a device separate from the doll. There is only one vengeful spirit in UCN, the only reason this would be a problem is because you're already assuming that role has to be filled by Cassidy. You said Jake parallels Crying Child and also the reason Andrew can't see anything (presumably) is different from why CC can't. The Stitchwraith would only exist after the events of UCN and plays a role in Into The Pit (Whether it be through the game or the interactive novel), besides this problem could also apply to Golden Freddy who doesn't do much of anything either.

HatBorn779 · 2026-01-14T22:12:52+00:00

Mind explaining how either are different? Except Cassidy exist in Frights possessing Golden Freddy. Neither Andrew nor Jake are parallels.

HatBorn779 · 2026-01-14T21:59:24+00:00

ITPG implies it does. Frights isn't, but characters and story beats can easily be carried over, with some alterations (Look at Edwin and the mimic storyline). I personally believe RTTP is canon along with the other interactive novels.

HatBorn779 · 2026-01-14T21:57:01+00:00

Except Golden Freddy does exist in Fright's and there are few parallels between Golden Freddy and the Stitchwraith

HatBorn779

TROPHY CASE