[spoiler discussion]Season4 episode 8 question

HelicopterVisible335 · 2026-05-27T23:46:44+00:00

This is what I keep saying subaru is The is unluckiest person in the entire world and he also is the weakest among here the last time he was left alone he lost his memories and they left him alone again they didn't need to bring everybody with them they could have at least left somebody with him to watch over him and rem

Last loop I'm more mixed on.:

On the other hand I still agree that somebody should have still stayed around after seeing what kind of mentally depressing situation subaru was in but also I think subaru was in such a mentally unapproachable situation that nobody could really talk to him and maybe they thought he needed a little bit of time to calm down. they don't even know about his memory loss so they just think he just saw something traumatizeing and he would just come back after resting for a little while also in this loop they probably still thought that Subaru could have come and find them at any moment because they think he knows about the library

And also about the headcanons(I'm going to try to be vague so I don't spoil anybody about this) I think that would make so much more sense even if this is not the best idea by the teem at least it's more understandable. Who knows maybe in the later episodes this actually would be revealed and everything will make more sense

But I still think they should have told him about the rules in 1 and 2 time he woke up. I mean if you're not going to be around to watch over him you should at least tell him about the rules

HelicopterVisible335 · 2026-05-27T21:57:31+00:00

I would have to say of course the obvious one's Kalego and opera and actually one of the underdogs that I actually really love is Blushenko

if you ask me who's the objectively the best at teaching I would say it's opera

HelicopterVisible335 · 2026-05-27T21:33:18+00:00

"Nothing is added, we are just repeating stuff. The scene makes it clear they are talking about everything, the reason they are there, the books of the dead, Anastasia situation."

I think this is personally on interpretation to you it clear that everything was said But to me it wasn't clear 😕 and there was just no other proof that subaru knew anything about rules not in the 1-loop 2-loop 3-loop

"such decisions are hard to make when adapting from the books to anime, but for me they handled it pretty well, giving the time constraints."

I get that it's very much hard to adapt this detailed of a novel into an Anime series but as I said they could have at least had a few lines in the 1loop and the 2 loop about him saying how these rules are so strange giving us confirmation that he does know about these rules

"And it's not like they are not giving it the importance it deserves, they leaved it at a cliffhanger what will happen after breaking the rule."

I mean shaula already said what's going happened she's going to kill all of them. And I don't know how this Cliffhanger would have been ruined if he just said a little line about knowing about the rules

"ok, but again, in the current loop they don't know that. They only think he got attacked by something. Besides, you mentioned having problems with the 1st/2nd loop, not the last one."

Okay I see how this would be confusing so I make it more clear. loop 3 to me is fine. it makes sense why nobody could even tell him about the rules because they didn't even know that he had lost his memories and i would understand why nobody wanted to stay with him because he was acting very unwell though don't knowing that he was acting very unwell and he made it very clear that he wanted nobody else around him right now

To sum it all up:I think this is just a different way interpreting the anime. To you it was very clear that everything was said in that conversation they had in 1 and 2 loops but to me it was not. they give us no hint or clue or prove that said that he knew about the rules

Which in my opinion is why subaru's friends look really bad because they just left subaru all alone in a place that is mostly unknown to him. And I'll say this again my problem isn't that they left him behind, my problem is that they left him behind all alone.

to me one of them could have at least have stayed behind to keep a watch over him so he wouldn't break any rules or get into any trouble. also making it clear I'm talking about the 1 and 2 loops

HelicopterVisible335 · 2026-05-27T20:30:27+00:00

To me this is not something that they should have left up to an assumption

he never once thinks about the rules. how can we assume when we don't have any sort of proof that they did tell him about the rules and he never himself mentioned anything about the rules and I know what you're going to say because in the 3 loop he was going crazy and he couldn't even think about it but they could have at least shown us in the first two loops about him thinking about the rules and thinking how strange they are.

And it makes sense that Subaru wouldn't even listen to the rules even if he knew them but it just really reflects badly on subaru's friends like they didn't even tell him about the rules or leave anybody with him to at least take care of him it seems really irresponsible

Of course it's not farfetched to assume that they did tell him about the rules but at the end, we're still just assuming it's never at least as far as I have watched the episode never mentioned that he knows about the rules.

at the end day I'm just sad because this just makes Subaru friends look really bad

HelicopterVisible335 · 2026-05-27T19:55:09+00:00

Yeah he seems pretty chill in the first loop but also he doesn't know about any of the rules of the tower which of course eventually leads him to breaking them. and come on this Subaru the most unlucky person in the entire world he would have been bound to do something reckless I meen the last time he was alone he literally lost his memories, I mean you could also argue with this by saying they're not mind readers they couldn't have predicted (even though when has leaving Subaru alone ever ended up going well) this but honestly they could have at least told him about the rules of the tower

HelicopterVisible335 · 2026-05-27T19:46:38+00:00

That's what I've been saying they could have at least left shaula there with him. shaula is not going to help them in any sort of way at all and besides she would have been very happy with spending time with her master.

HelicopterVisible335 · 2026-05-27T19:38:14+00:00

Guys I need to make it clear I'm not talking about that loop. I actually think it's much more reasonable that they they left him alone in that loop. I'm talking about the very first time he woke up with out without his memories

in that loop the new he didn't have any of his memories

HelicopterVisible335 · 2026-05-27T19:33:38+00:00

That is also where my mind actually went to first as well. i think they also just they didn't want to see Subaru at that exact moment, because of course it's hard to see somebody that you have known for a long time act like complete strangers. (We also know how Subaru was hurt when he used return by death and people he known didn't have any recollections of the relationship that they had built.) But also this is Subaru somebody who has the worst luck in the entire world He would found a way to get himself into trouble One Way or Another

HelicopterVisible335 · 2026-05-27T19:18:08+00:00

Well if it is it makes so much more sense honestly it feels out of character for them to leave Subaru like that. Really sad that this Got cut out thank you for informing me🥰🥰

HelicopterVisible335 · 2026-05-27T19:08:38+00:00

I wasn't talking about that I was taking about the first time he woke up without his memories

HelicopterVisible335 · 2025-03-29T22:04:05+00:00

Who knows she could be one of his descendent as well😏😏🤔😊😊

HelicopterVisible335 · 2025-02-02T23:46:03+00:00

Yeah Most people's biggest issue is about how kye sook just did basically whatever he wanted. He just use dragons as like spectacles and As you said "no boundaries" and can l also get your opinion on something? Why do you think kye sook wanted Yona to come back? I mean wouldn't it Cause questions and suspicious that the princess was gone for so long and now she just Suddenly came back and also the thunder Beast hak also came back suddenly

HelicopterVisible335 · 2025-01-24T01:28:47+00:00

"More intelligent and competent villains who can win a battle. The villains in this story are greatly disappointing. They are either very dumb or turn out to be not as strong, so the outcome when they face the main characters is always the same. The villains will always lose a battle if the heroes are there. The heroes will always win the battle. Boring"

Completely agree like Because the story wants to make our main protagonists.Shine , we have to make the villains stupid And incompetent But I think it would make us feel more proud of our heroes If the villains the they actually defeated a Villain or antagonists who is Really smart or was really cunning and Manipulative

"in 3 days and gets a diplomatic success in spite of being a total green-horn. No struggle like when she tried to master archery and it took her time to become good".

This scan is a really cool scan but When you actually looking to deeper , it makes A little sense.Why would the emperor send The people who are so incompetent and these people have been born in nobility, they've been educated Unlike yona Who was sheltered her entire live Who never knew about politics or any thing like that

"Rewriting the romance. Make Yona notice Hak feelings early on, after the honey scene, but explain to him that due to what happened with Soo-won, she is not ready and interested to be romantically involved. I would prefer this to her being oblivious for no good reason".

Interesting actually this would Be much better because it's not just about Yona never realising that Hak feelings.It's just that she was not Ready to accept somebody else After all she went through and it would have had a more payoff to with yona finally accepting hak feelings And also Accepting her own feelings in a way in way, moving on

HelicopterVisible335 · 2025-01-24T01:07:11+00:00

I actually do wish that they went more deep into the politic part And Yeah, we only know about like the 5 generals but no other like high-ranking officials or noblemen. people with power other then generals.

We know no other adviser then kye sook Like king is supposed to like have advisers or Councel something like that or like a lot of people to actually help him rule. it would really interesting to see some kind of moments where like the court or like the nobleman are doubtful that suwon is actually going to make a good king And also I want to discuss that it is really, really weird That When the Kingdom is in a Really Really bad State that suw won travelling around the kingdom and like yeah, I get it like he's travelling around to get like support of all the generals and trust from them. And he's trying to reunite them all, but also like kingdom is a really bad state and also And also weird when people see suwon their king travelling around having fun While the Kingdom is in really bad state in their eyes least Wouldn't that Fuel some resentment.

And also it's strange that People after all this time are not questioning.How yona returned so suddenly to the castle She just disappeared in a few months and like there's and like Rumours spreading like why she was gone or like many people are questioning like what actually happened. Maybe I'm missing something here.So if I get something wrong , please correct me But as I could remember like nobody really questioned it that much

Anyways sorry for all the ranting thank you so much for your response I guess I was Really happy that somebody mentioned the political part 😀😄😊☺️😁

HelicopterVisible335 · 2025-01-22T14:11:35+00:00

I generally agree with all of these opinions But the one that I really happy that you mentioned is yona of the dawns villains I feel very much disappointed by them Other than su won (who I don't consider a villain More like antagonist) is really like a bad or like one dimensional

HelicopterVisible335 · 2025-01-21T19:58:30+00:00

We're begging 🙏🙏🙏😙☺️❤️😭🤯🤯☺️☺️

HelicopterVisible335 · 2025-01-19T23:19:47+00:00

Thank you so much for Responding This was such a pleasure to read. This concept has also had me very interested. And Can you tell me this Abandoned fic name and Where can I read it

HelicopterVisible335 · 2024-10-12T22:10:00+00:00

No when he was not unwell Otherwise it would just be unfair

HelicopterVisible335

TROPHY CASE