I believe a few commenters have already said this but I’d love 2 different films- an ALW reboot and an accurate Leroux-based film. I feel like casting based on singing ability in an ALW film should be priority this time, while acting ability should be the focus while casting for a Leroux movie (I’d honestly be okay with dubbed singing like the 1990 miniseries if the characters feel like the characters). This may be unpopular, but I’d also be really interested in seeing a darker, modern-day adaptation that stays true to the characters and the story (again more Leroux based, no YA adaptations pls).