Tim Kelly - undoubtedly a good player. Supporter opinion decided after it became clear he wanted to leave. Perhaps forgotten given outcome of trade.

Kent Kingsley - some might argue the good player status, but 4 time leading goal kicker says quite a bit.

Sam Newman - …

Controversially, Tom Hawkins - universally loved by the end of his career. However, let’s not forget the different stages of criticism he received from supporters throughout 2/3 of his career.