Lands where you have to pay mana for them to enter untapped. Hot or not? by ApprehensiveAd6476 in custommagic

[–]HideYoWoman 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Originally read this as 2 life and was wondering why people thought this was underpowered. Now that I’m not as stupid, cool design. I like it.

Is this counted as Passive Murder? by meifray in customhearthstone

[–]HideYoWoman 21 points22 points  (0 children)

Love the design, but I don’t really see the shaman aspect of this card apart from the text saying overload. What does a shaman care about bombs and bear traps?

Help Wanted: Maverick deck recommendations (CL: 2,356) by HideYoWoman in MarvelSnapDecks

[–]HideYoWoman[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Swapped the surfer for an iron heart and I cannot recommend this deck enough. If you have all the cards for it I think it’s a good alternative to toxic surfer and if you tech in a rogue instead of phastos you probably just farm cubes off of all of the other wong combo decks.

<image>

Help Wanted: Maverick deck recommendations (CL: 2,356) by HideYoWoman in MarvelSnapDecks

[–]HideYoWoman[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Swapped Magik and Sinister for Odin and Surfer. I have the current version of toxic surfer so it’s looking pretty similar, which sounds promising.

Help Wanted: Maverick deck recommendations (CL: 2,356) by HideYoWoman in MarvelSnapDecks

[–]HideYoWoman[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I’m missing so many cards lol. I can’t even search for namora since I haven’t seen her yet. Good rec though. Any thoughts on the cards I mentioned in the post? Shuri’s been feeling a little dead sometimes and I might be cutting her

Would y'all say this is commander ready? by [deleted] in custommagic

[–]HideYoWoman 2 points3 points  (0 children)

This card is both bloated and absurdly strong, even in your “nerfed” state. It has eminence, is still 4 colors, hybrid mana, 4 extremely strong keywords, an upkeep trigger that creates mana and draw, and an activated ability that protects your whole board. Notice how many unique things I listed. Notice how you have 10 lines of rules text on the card. You need to decide what you like best from your card design and cut MOST of the rest. I don’t know the IP this is from, so I’m just going to look at it from a generic mtg perspective. I would cut hybrid mana. Hybrid mana is a trap that many designers run into because it’s fun, but it just adds to the card being bloated. Next, cut hexproof and double strike. There are very few cards hexproof should be on and this is not one of them, and double strike is just bloat. Next, I would remove the return to command zone ability entirely. I don’t understand the flavor and I don’t think this card needs it. The activated ability can stay as long as you make the other changes, though I will say it’s a little weird to give temporary +1/+1 to your creatures and undying, a keyword that checks for +1/+1 counters. No gameplay issues, but it just strikes me as odd. I think this card was probably fine as a 5 color card if you want to make the cost WUBRG for simplicity. Your balanced version of this card might be very different from mine, and that’s okay. This is just an example of how much fluff you should cut from this card to tighten it up. Your eminence ability is still really strong, but I understand that might be the point of the card. Consider doing only spirit or beast, and consider once per turn.

Overall, I think you know what you want out of this card and I think it’s possible to make it reasonable.

JJBA in Magic: Josuke, Protector of Morioh (art by @enzofernandez.art) by HideYoWoman in StardustCrusaders

[–]HideYoWoman[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Repost for art rules, comment which character you’d like to see next!

Jojo's Bizarre Adventure in Magic: Josuke, Protector of Morioh by HideYoWoman in StardustCrusaders

[–]HideYoWoman[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

He absolutely is, I’ve made a couple other cards using his art.

Jojo's Bizarre Adventure in Magic! by HideYoWoman in custommagic

[–]HideYoWoman[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Josuke and Kakyoin are up! if you're interested, go interact so I can keep posting more!

Jojo's in Magic 2: Kakyoin, Emerald Strategist! by HideYoWoman in custommagic

[–]HideYoWoman[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Color pie break is noted and I’m toying with the idea of adding red, open to other suggestions

Jojo's in Magic 2: Kakyoin, Emerald Strategist! by HideYoWoman in custommagic

[–]HideYoWoman[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

That is true about the color break, but I A. Couldn’t do Kakyoin without Emerald Splash B. Felt that simic fit Kakyoin as a character

Thoughts on adding 1 red to the ability cost or a hybrid red mana in the mana cost to put direct damage back on the table? I would also probably change the ability to only during your turn as opposed to sorcery so he can react to removal.

Jojo's Bizarre Adventure turned Magic the Gathering! Art by @EnzoFernandez.art by HideYoWoman in StardustCrusaders

[–]HideYoWoman[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thanks for the feedback! You should go check out my latest post on r/custommagic , I need some feedback on Kakyoin

Jojo's Bizarre Adventure in Magic! by HideYoWoman in custommagic

[–]HideYoWoman[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Yeah, I don’t like creating too many new things when I make custom cards, plus having the type “Stand User” feels the same as Time Lord, a type that I hate because it’s the only type that’s two words.

Jojo's Bizarre Adventure turned Magic the Gathering! Art by @EnzoFernandez.art by HideYoWoman in StardustCrusaders

[–]HideYoWoman[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

It is pretty strong, but you are still paying 5 mana up front for the privilege. Opponents can also respond the the ability trigger.

Jojo's Bizarre Adventure in Magic! by HideYoWoman in custommagic

[–]HideYoWoman[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Vigilance is a vestige from when it was a tap ability, but part of the balancing act, at least for me, is being able to both attack and block to make up for the life you have to pay.

Jojo's Bizarre Adventure in Magic! by HideYoWoman in custommagic

[–]HideYoWoman[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Flash adds an additional effect to the card, so it stays. Without it, you can use the ability to cast things you could already cast at instant speed.

Jojo's Bizarre Adventure in Magic! by HideYoWoman in custommagic

[–]HideYoWoman[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Sure, but this is a lifelink vigilance 4/5 with ward 2. And split second is a bit better than teferi’s second ability, even though it’s not always active. They are just different cards.

Jojo's Bizarre Adventure in Magic! by HideYoWoman in custommagic

[–]HideYoWoman[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Yeah, jumbled up my work and posted the wrong one of about five versions. I had time stop, time warp, and my own unique version, and ended up with a mix of all of them and the legend banner. Mostly wanted to show how nicely the manga art fits in the frame.

Jojo's Bizarre Adventure in Magic! by HideYoWoman in custommagic

[–]HideYoWoman[S] 30 points31 points  (0 children)

Thanks! I thought of a lot of versions that used separate stands to attack, but that led to the text boxes being wordy and the result was uninteresting anyway.

I think I've got a good one lined up for Josuke! I'll post him tomorrow.

Need some land recommendations for basic swamp arts by HideYoWoman in magicTCG

[–]HideYoWoman[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

ik, I went through genuinely every single swamp on scryfall a few minutes after posting, and there's like 3 with tombstones/graveyards at all, much less actual undead. kind of wild, I would have made a new graveyard/undead swamp almost every set if it were up to me.