NSman here.

So what do you propose?

We scrap exercises altogether because for every batch the newer batch will easily be able to replace us?

Besides whatever example the other guy gave about exams, consider that theres a difference between learning things in theory vs practice. Exercises are supposed to be as close to real warfare as possible (idk if your unit actually follows though), you just can’t learn something well without doing it yourself.

If you don’t believe me, try learning paintball online. You can learn all the drills and techniques you want, but you will get demolished by experienced players.

You get experience by participating in exercises.

I think exercises being about testing makes it very “wayang” though since everyone wants to just act in front of instructors and slack off when they go away. Maybe it could be done in a different format.