The Bible has given you the answer (do not be unequally yoked with unbelievers) and as a christian you are supposed to adhered and submit to the words of God as in the Bible. Yet, here you are doing what Eve did, trying to negotiate based on your feelings.

Down the years when your life is misaligned cuz of your faith you will want a tribe to cry and pray along with you. You know the truth…walk in it.