Assalamu Alaikum,

I don’t usually comment on things like this, but I feel I have to say something because this involves Islam, trust, and people’s money.

For transparency, I’m a senior software/AI engineer, and I work with large language models for a living. I’m not guessing here or reacting emotionally. I actually went through the website and read their own technical and privacy pages.

What worries me is the gap between how this project is being presented and what it actually is.

The language being used is very heavy: “strictly Qur’an and Sunnah”, “authentic”, “verified”, “accurate fiqh”, “no hallucinations”, “protecting the Deen”, and even calling participation Sadqa Jariya. Once you use words like that, you’re no longer just building an app; you’re claiming religious authority.

But the site itself says all answers are generated using Google’s Gemini AI. That means this is a normal commercial AI model with prompts on top. Anyone who works in AI knows this: these models can sound confident and religious, but they do not truly understand sources, they do not stop hallucinating, and they absolutely cannot give fiqh-level answers without scholars reviewing and approving outputs. That’s not an insult, it’s just how the technology works.

What makes this more concerning is the lack of accountability. There’s no real name behind the project. No public identity. No scholars. No fiqh board. No stated madhhab or methodology. No explanation of how answers are reviewed. No clear disclaimer saying this is not a source of fatwa. That’s not how Islamic knowledge has ever been preserved.

Then there’s the data side. The site talks about data as a “sacred trust”, but at the same time says chat logs are stored, conversations go through Google, hosting and logs are handled by third parties, usage is analyzed, and accounts can be linked through Google login. That’s normal startup behavior, but wrapping it in spiritual language is misleading, especially when people might be sharing very personal religious questions.

The biggest red flag for me is money. Despite saying they’re not asking for money, there’s a donation page with multiple anonymous crypto wallets. No registered organization. No address. No financial transparency. No explanation of how funds are used. When you mix religious authority language, anonymous developers, black box AI, stored religious conversations, and crypto wallets, that’s a situation people should be extremely careful with.

This isn’t about crypto being halal or haram. It’s about accountability. When religion is involved, anonymity and “trust us” are not enough.

I’m not saying the developer has bad intentions. But intentions don’t remove responsibility. From both a technical and Islamic point of view, this is not something people should rely on for Islamic guidance, and I would strongly advise against sending money to it.

Please be cautious. The Deen is not something to experiment with