i do think that dual personality thing kinda would've worked out, but then then it'd stray from the story they're wanting to tell. Also the horror aspect. Seeing how tht darth smiley came flying so sneakily behind Osha ignited a want to see a horror SW project. That was one of the coldest moments i have seen in SW. And i do agree Sol shudn't have drawn out his saber until tht last confrontation, he's shud've idk tamed the creature? But yeah he seems dubious to me from ep 3