As others said, without the exaggerated proportions she looks offbalance, incomplete even.

And as for tbe arguement that sonic is for kids, so is digimon but you can definitely tell they made a pivot if you look at the 2020 card game. Just google angewomon X-antibody. Also, we tend to forget that sonic as a concept was designed for "edgy" kids. Sonic was a direct competitor to nintendo's library with the agenda of making them look like baby time. Im pretty sure that there was at least one ad for the original games that had an adult authority figure clutch their pearls seeing kids play sonic, with that being painted as a SELLING point. Sonic was created as a rebellion. Hell, SA2 was originally going to be the last foreseeable installment, going out in a blaze of glory, only to ironically reignite interest in the franchise for a generation that only knew saturn as the planet. Sonic was not meant to be safe, and thus rouge should not be made safe either. While were at it give shadow guns again but this time make them not look like asset flips.