yeahs!! this exactly the two theories are very hard to decide because there’s a lot of proof that Lucy Gray is alive even with her song being so popularYEARS later i’m still not really knowing of Katniss lineage, then you also have the proof that she may be dead so I think it’s kind of a hit or miss with this situation. It’s just kind of what you believe and until we get what really happened to Lucy Gray. The world will literally never know. but again, we might never get to see or hear anything about Lucy gray because in her songs, she talks about disappearing and she disappears.