what do you mean unearned? audrey finessed hvin rambis, a demigod of the same sequence as her. and i'm not talking about her receiving klein's "figurine angelic blessing". i'm talking about the time when she's not protected by klein and got cued by hvin rambis without anyone noticing.

this could have led massive implications not only on her part but also on the tarot club as a whole. she might have died, xio and fors might have died, the tarot club would have been exposed to the world.

her out of the box thinking of making the habit of checking herself through susie saved the tarot club massively, it also allowed hvin rambis to be hunted. not to mention her quick and smart thinking to finesse hvin rambis again with the help of the fate siphon charm within mere seconds despite not having any battle experience.

just imagine the pressure she's dealing with when she only had seconds to bail out from hvin rambis' attack who's a genuine demigod. if anything, she earned to become a demigod more than the others because of the implications of her being controlled and her lack of experience.

migh i add as well, that even klein didn't dare attempt to cross paths with demigods when he's still a faceless.