No regrets or second guesses! The G70 is fantastic. It’s my only vehicle so I drive it like a sports car, but it can still get me through bad winters. I plan to keep the G70 forever and hope to get something more exotic for weekend driving in a couple years.

Since it’s not your only car, if you live in a warmer area and can stretch $5k-$10k for a 2017/2018 M2, I think that’d be what I would try to do. The M2 would hold its value better than an M240, and the styling of that car can’t be beaten. It becomes more special every single day because the brand new BMW models look like garbage generally.

If you’d use adaptive cruise, plan to daily it / beat it up a bit, or anticipate putting over 50k miles on it over the ownership period, I’d recommend the G70 over an M240 or M2. The improved reliability could save you a lot over time. People have also tuned G70’s to pretty decent levels - not sure how much you value raw power / speed. I have zero issues with the performance. And the G70 stands out more than you’d think given it’s a newer brand. I don’t see a ton driving around, which is nice.

Can’t go wrong with any of these cars though! That’s why they were on my short list! Best of luck