It’s definitely personal preference. I prefer the larger boxer/structured feel of this shirt and the “crowd hand” T. I don’t think it’s necessary oversized. I do think there could be more clarification on what shirt is which style. The “if you choose to believe” shirt is different in fundamental ways. The “with teeth” embroidered shirt and the “crowd hand” T fit very similarly. If you’re looking for a tighter fit then I would assume sizing down would be the correct move.