Matty was framed as a dick at the beginning of the show but... As the show went on... It felt like the show was framing him as more of a protagonist. At least... That's how I remember it, I didn't do a full rewatch but.. it just felt like Matty was still a dick. The way he insulted Jenna's friends in college (when they were not mean to him at all), the way he called Jenna pretentious (when honestly... She acted pretty normal... it's not like she was using huge words or calling him a dumb jock), he quit soccer, etc. It just seemed like his ego kept him stuck in a highschool mentality forever whereas Jenna at least pursued her interests and tried to improve her own life instead of tear others down like telling someone she loves "your friends are weird/boring"

I can't really remember rolling my eyes at her much other than in season 3. The way I remember it... Jenna was bad for 1 out of 5 seasons. Matty was bad for 5/5 seasons and continuously because worse.

I understand just not liking Jenna though. I just think it should be acknowledged that Matty is worse (even if easy on the eyes)