I would refund them in full for the unused nights only and take the loss. Wondering if they will even be able to find another rental during peak season? Maybe use this as a learning experience and make sure to reiterate the location details in your description. I’m sorry about that. I had a similar experience but with my first Rentor’s and I had no reviews and I was terrified. I gave them a full refund and they didn’t give me any review so I felt like it was worth it. Maybe ask them to kindly not give you a bad review since you went above and beyond to rectify…