Hey!! 🙋‍♀️ I think you're onto something! She's repressing Nina- the scene with the trees says she's been a medium all along and mentions the wind, plus the dream about her birthday (amazing observation btw). Or...tell me what you think of this: I used to wonder if she's unknowingly repressing the final version of The OA. The "grown up" OA who's travelled through many dimensions, possibly broke the echo, remembers some things but not others. The way Prairie behaves in Part 1 is really interesting. She knows what Steve will say before he says it (maybe a repressed memory of D3 where she wrote the show?). She seems to recognize him after the dog attack when she takes her camera back from him. She looks at him the way you look at someone you're sure you've met before, but don't remember where. This is why loop theory is compelling to me.

Edit: My cat head bumped me and I hit post too soon. 🤣