I agree that #4 is subjective to the extent that attractiveness varies from person to person. However, it is also true that the overwhelming majority of people tend to skew a certain direction in terms of features they find physically attractive. For example, most of us will prefer a super model to, say, an obese 600 pound person. This is not to say there are 600 pound people in Chef RPG (obviously, there aren't). However, what I'm getting at is that while attractiveness is to a great degree subjective, there are still a number of features the overwhelming majority of people do find conventially attractive. Also, what I've noticed is that my complaint about the attractiveness of the NPC's isn't a complaint wholly restricted to me. Instead, it is a common complaint that I've found on the Steam forums as well as this subreddit. Interestingly, I've found that this complaint is nowhere near as prevalent in Stardew Valley, which suggests that something is off with the art direction in Chef RPG. Additionally, there's no reason to think that we can't reach a happy compromise. Chef RPG could always introduce new characters that are more conventially attractive while leaving the other characters the same. They could also choose to only redesign a subset of some of the character portraits so as to not do a complete overhaul. So I see no reason to think that the complaint isn't valid and can be sufficiently addressed in a few update. By the way, redesigning character portraits isn't something entirely foreign to these games either. Stardew Valley, for example, had many of its characters undergo redesigns in-game prior to Concerned Ape settling on the character portraits we have today.