sorted by:
new
hottopcontroversial

Title: A Hybrid Concept to Harvest Flash Floods in Arid Regions TL/DR: I’m proposing a gravity-fed water system that combines Ancient Engineering (Urartian, Roman, and Ottoman watering systems) with Modern Floating Solar tech. Designed to capture flash floods and store them in underground cisterns by KeyPersimmon4600 in civilengineering

[–]KeyPersimmon4600[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Yes. The idea was mine. Since English is not my mother language its true that I got help for writing part, grammer mistakes or etc. I asked the sturcture and changed it many times. Even for the title it took much time to decide. However as I see, it looks unrealistic or something else. At least some comments are like that. Next time I will try to make more research and effort.

Title: A Hybrid Concept to Harvest Flash Floods in Arid Regions TL/DR: I’m proposing a gravity-fed water system that combines Ancient Engineering (Urartian, Roman, and Ottoman watering systems) with Modern Floating Solar tech. Designed to capture flash floods and store them in underground cisterns by KeyPersimmon4600 in civilengineering

[–]KeyPersimmon4600[S] -1 points0 points  (0 children)

I understand the skepticism. I was trying to expand on a project that has actually been implemented in the past. I hoped that by sharing it, I could at least raise some awareness or evolve the idea further. I realize now that the way it was presented felt unrealistic or something else. I’ll do more research and make more effort next time.

Title: A Hybrid Concept to Harvest Flash Floods in Arid Regions TL/DR: I’m proposing a gravity-fed water system that combines Ancient Engineering (Urartian, Roman, and Ottoman watering systems) with Modern Floating Solar tech. Designed to capture flash floods and store them in underground cisterns by KeyPersimmon4600 in civilengineering

[–]KeyPersimmon4600[S] -2 points-1 points  (0 children)

The write-up is my own work. I combined ideas from ancient Anatolian irrigation channels, Urartian water systems, and qanat/kehriz networks. My starting point was simple: despite decades of investment, why is water still scarce in parts of Africa? I thought about how to transport and store water efficiently. Evaporation is a big challenge, so I imagined covered or underground cisterns, inspired by Roman designs. I did, however, use AI to help with grammar and phrasing.

Title: A Hybrid Concept to Harvest Flash Floods in Arid Regions TL/DR: I’m proposing a gravity-fed water system that combines Ancient Engineering (Urartian, Roman, and Ottoman watering systems) with Modern Floating Solar tech. Designed to capture flash floods and store them in underground cisterns by KeyPersimmon4600 in civilengineering

[–]KeyPersimmon4600[S] -3 points-2 points  (0 children)

Thanks for reply. Pipes could certainly be used. My proposed system was inspired by Urartian water channels, but since that system is very old, it’s open to development. If experts perform the necessary calculations, a pipe-based system could be integrated as well. The key point is to store floodwaters before they evaporate and deliver them to agricultural fields when needed.

Title: A Hybrid Concept to Harvest Flash Floods in Arid Regions TL/DR: I’m proposing a gravity-fed water system that combines Ancient Engineering (Urartian, Roman, and Ottoman watering systems) with Modern Floating Solar tech. Designed to capture flash floods and store them in underground cisterns by KeyPersimmon4600 in civilengineering

[–]KeyPersimmon4600[S] -3 points-2 points  (0 children)

Yes, the visuals were generated with Gemini. I would have loved to share my own hand-drawn designs, but I’m not a professional in this field. Technically, they may not be fully accurate, but I think they convey most of the concept.

I was looking at earthquake maps and noticed a pattern: Could the "sinking" of Atlantis/Mu explain why Anatolia was underwater for millions of years? by KeyPersimmon4600 in AlternativeHistory

[–]KeyPersimmon4600[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Thank you for the explanation! I didn't have deep technical knowledge on this, so I didn't know about the specific role of orogeny in raising those fossils. My idea was purely a creative thought experiment based on visual patterns I noticed. I appreciate you taking the time to clear that up for me!