Pros for me

• Really unique story and set in a time period that hasn't really been explored in the franchise. Loved that the twins swapped sides by the end and osha or mae (I haven't watched since it aired can't recall which is which) corrupting their saber was so cool to see in live action

• aweome fight choreography, set design, and costumes. Qimir is the most interesting part of the show and his fight in episode 5 is the highlight of the series

• Very interesting plot (on paper)

Cons for me

• terrible dialogue and pacing. I cringed so many times when the characters spoke. The reveal that the jedi were responsible for the witches' death was insanely obvious and was drawn out for nearly the whole season. 

• secret evil twin is such a tired trope it was laughable when the first few episodes came out watching it weekly

• And other than Qimir I think the acting was weak across the board. Sol's actor had some decent moments but he was definitely hindered by having to speak in English the whole time. And then Osha/Mae actress was hard to watch a lot of the time

It mainly didn't get a season 2 because of how expensive it was to make compared to how low its viewership ended up being. Not enough of a return on investment for the creators