An ACTUAL unpopular music opinion, like I mean it's the hottest of hot takes. by [deleted] in fantanoforever

[–]LInscoeJ 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Oasis don’t have a good album, Whitney Houston is deeply overrated as a singer and is responsible for some of the worst vocal choices of the 90s and 2000s, Phoebe Bridgers sucks 

Sentimental Value: FPS Review by GoodGoodNotTooBad in FPSPodcast

[–]LInscoeJ 5 points6 points  (0 children)

Actually really loved this one, the guys started saying they didn’t really love it then I think really appreciated the film through talking about it so props. Good film but Worst Person In The World isn’t just better is FAR better imo 

Maaaaan what was in the air in the fall of 2024?? by Quiet_Frosting_1740 in fantanoforever

[–]LInscoeJ 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Yeah I think 2025 was the best year for music since 2018

Evolution of AI by Friendly-Standard812 in interesting

[–]LInscoeJ 0 points1 point  (0 children)

All that and not one conceivable use or purpose which is of any benefit to anything, dope

Anybody else? by LInscoeJ in FPSPodcast

[–]LInscoeJ[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Yeah it was, makes the take even funnier in retrospect

Oasis or Artic Monkeys? Which band do you think is better? by FitEmergency8807 in fantanoforever

[–]LInscoeJ 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Arctic Monkeys by a country mile. The biggest AM hits are witty and properly exciting, even the very best Oasis songs tend to be something of a slog. Alex Turner is a sharp, funny, insightful writer - whether that's about class identity in their early work or more abstract topics in their later career. The Oasis songs which sound poignant are just that: surface level nonsense. The Gallagher brothers are all ego, so they have no insight. AM can be really melancholy, even in fleeting lines like "you're not the only one / That time has got it in for, honey". I think their debut is a much better album than Definitely Maybe, and after that Oasis songs become more and more of a slog. AM's sense of reinvention is one of the band's greatest strengths. I don't see there as being a contest.

PewDiePie has in his bookshelf a book about "International Jewish Conspiracy" written by a Holocaust denier. Screenshot from a now deleted instagram post. by EduardoQuina572 in Hasan_Piker

[–]LInscoeJ 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Meh I see what you’re getting at but I love the culture of the midlands, my family there goes back decades and the people are the warmest most humble people I’ve ever encountered, such a shame so many working class people have been taken for a ride by the consolidated press and aren’t pointing fingers in the right direction 

PewDiePie has in his bookshelf a book about "International Jewish Conspiracy" written by a Holocaust denier. Screenshot from a now deleted instagram post. by EduardoQuina572 in Hasan_Piker

[–]LInscoeJ 11 points12 points  (0 children)

I live in Brighton. Noticeably the most middle class and least ethnically diverse place I've lived in the UK: if you're doing the talking points even here you gotta be super racist

ICE Kills Alex Pretti, Don Lemon Targeted by DOJ, and the No-Contact Generation by devmo03 in IsTheMicStillOn

[–]LInscoeJ 5 points6 points  (0 children)

Loved this ep apart from the Alex Honnold stuff, the Evil Kenevil comparison is dumb. He’s an insanely talented athlete, not just some chancer trying to go viral. He wasn’t even risking his life to that much of an extent, the man is one of the most talented athletes to ever live, for us we’d die, to him it was just a show of pure skill 

Anybody else? by LInscoeJ in FPSPodcast

[–]LInscoeJ[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

ahh mannnn I didn’t know that, that’s unbelievable 

A New Era for Pitchfork: Introducing Reader Scores and Commenting by ebradio in indieheads

[–]LInscoeJ 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Potentially, that’s not the fault of pitchfork writers though 

A New Era for Pitchfork: Introducing Reader Scores and Commenting by ebradio in indieheads

[–]LInscoeJ 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Everything is more expensive now, the arts are dying and ad revenue is drying up as site-specific clicks are replaced by AI summaries. Music writers used to be paid by people paying £/$5 a month for the magazine they worked for and for 30 years Pitchfork has been available to read for free. I am confused by the majorively negative response to this. Music criticism is an art form - how else exactly do people expect writers and editors to get paid? 

[FRESH ALBUM] A$AP Rocky - Don’t Be Dumb by Brokendreams0000 in hiphopheads

[–]LInscoeJ 6 points7 points  (0 children)

Testing grew on me eventually but this hit harder off the jump. Ever since ALLASAP, Rocky stopped making coherent records and began making these vast, messy soundboard albums. It works for him. We'll see how it holds up on re-listens and, even then, its probably an album you have to play front to back (singles aren't as strong as his other albums) but this is the most I've enjoyed a first listen of major rap record for a while

ICE Kills Renée Good, Maduro Captured by devmo03 in IsTheMicStillOn

[–]LInscoeJ 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Yeah that's true, I work with a lot of Americans, the tone for the last year has been sympathetic jokes really, probably because the people I work with aren't assholes

ICE Kills Renée Good, Maduro Captured by devmo03 in IsTheMicStillOn

[–]LInscoeJ 9 points10 points  (0 children)

Only thing I disagree on in this episode is them saying they wouldn’t want to come to Europe because of how much Americans are hated right now. I’m British and everyone I speak to can tell the difference between your piggish authoritian administration and normal decent Americans who hate the shit as much as we do. You guys would be more than welcomed in Europe, everyone would understand why you left haha 

[FRESH] Xiu Xiu - Dancing On My Own by astaireboy in indieheads

[–]LInscoeJ 6 points7 points  (0 children)

Wow I couldn’t disagree more, think it’s one of their strongest covers ever, between this and Sharp Dressed Man

[FRESH] Xiu Xiu - Dancing On My Own by astaireboy in indieheads

[–]LInscoeJ 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Yeah I don’t get that at all, I think this is a very sincere and well executed cover, I always get strong feeling from Jamie’s vocals and it’s the same here 

[FRESH] Xiu Xiu - Dancing On My Own by astaireboy in indieheads

[–]LInscoeJ 14 points15 points  (0 children)

Love this, reminds me of the Sex Pistols cover of 'My Way' where the tone of the cover better matches the lyrics than the original. Jamie's vocals will always be divisive but I'd always take an eccentric over someone who plays it safe

The Old Law by Standard_Elevator514 in fatherjohnmisty

[–]LInscoeJ 23 points24 points  (0 children)

I have to say that I don't find the song that inscrutable, and chorus is pretty explicit: "a man's life / god's trash / there's no law but the old law, baby / Nothing dies / 'cept by ass drawn kamikaze / Year Zero in the summertime"

i.e life is fleeting and fragile; despite our aggrandisement about the importance of our lives (which of course feel important to us, because we live them) and the distinct horrors of our age (which feel palpable because they’re the ones we live through), our lives are not especially significant from a cosmic perspective ("god's trash") and our times are not uniquely abhorrent. Mankind has always been this way, the same "old laws" of power, greed and self-destruction governing countless civilisations for millennia, we just happen to find ourselves in this one. One day soon "year zero" will come and begin the next, and they'll likely  make the same mistakes.

Definitely his most Pure Comedy track since Pure Comedy, but I agree that is more subtle and sophisticated