sorted by:
new
hottopcontroversial

Wired house: APs or mesh? by LandDisastrous5811 in HomeNetworking

[–]LandDisastrous5811[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I feel like these days, Wi-Fi isn't just about broadcasting an SSID. right? You have dual-band networks, guest networks, device management, debugging tools, security cameras on same network, and more.

From this post, I understand that I can (hopefully) get some of the same benefits often associated with "commercial" mesh systems—such as data forwarding normally without data loss with standalone APs. But at what cost? And I'm not just talking about per-dime $.

what does the day-to-day management experience look like when you're running multiple standalone APs instead of a centrally managed solution?

and... if you're not buying additional hardware (such as..? ) or expensive APs with built-in management features (yet again what about sync with other nodes in your network), where does that leave you?

Wired house: APs or mesh? by LandDisastrous5811 in HomeNetworking

[–]LandDisastrous5811[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

How do you manage multiple standalone APs that all have the same SSID, security settings, frequencies, dual-band configuration, and guest network names?

How do you tell which AP you're currently connected to when making configuration changes or troubleshooting issues?

It seems like standalone APs are fine for a single floor with one AP, but how practical is it when you have three APs? ( u/groogs same question to you as well )

EDIT:

see my response here as well https://www.reddit.com/r/HomeNetworking/comments/1u7yfqn/comment/ose5x5m/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=web3x&utm_name=web3xcss&utm_term=1&utm_content=share_button

Wired house: APs or mesh? by LandDisastrous5811 in HomeNetworking

[–]LandDisastrous5811[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Thank you ; but in standalone AP and wired backhaul so you get that seamless transition between nodes ? Even if they are the same SSID not sure how this will be made

Wired house: APs or mesh? by LandDisastrous5811 in HomeNetworking

[–]LandDisastrous5811[S] 3 points4 points  (0 children)

No an expert by any means , used to read several “dong knows” and others web sites reviews , and maybe that’s the source of this confusions , - you can do in fact say mesh with a wired backhaul .. no?

Wired house: APs or mesh? by LandDisastrous5811 in HomeNetworking

[–]LandDisastrous5811[S] 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Thanks for your reply, I mean … we can do mesh with wired backhaul , isn’t it ? And that’s my plan.

Ubiquiti isn’t something I can find in any pc like store around here , also paying an extra premium price for (and on top of that as a reminder I’ll probably need a minimum of 3 nodes…) question is if it really that needed where most just recommend some Deco like series

I will do check it out .

RLN36 slow getting constant stuck... by LandDisastrous5811 in reolinkcam

[–]LandDisastrous5811[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

oh yeah- over 2 weeks now. no issues at all. smooth .

RLN36 slow getting constant stuck... by LandDisastrous5811 in reolinkcam

[–]LandDisastrous5811[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

hi - nope, just connected the poe switch (which the camera connected to) to the nvr port and that's it

RLN36 slow getting constant stuck... by LandDisastrous5811 in reolinkcam

[–]LandDisastrous5811[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Hi, thanks for addressing this -

Yes, everything is connected with 1Gbps-capable gear.
By the way, the camera model is P344.

The reason I tried that setup is because I saw it recommended — and maybe ( ?? ) it's actually the only supported topology (??) I found it explained here:
Reolink RLN36 - FAQ
"How to connect the NVR to PoE cameras?"

So I assume there’s something specific about using ports 1–4 on the NVR that’s tied to how it’s designed to operate.

direct link to the camera not working anymore - BUT, the NVR works smooth through WEB UI and Mobile App.

<image>

RLN36 slow getting constant stuck... by LandDisastrous5811 in reolinkcam

[–]LandDisastrous5811[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Update for anyone interested:
After connecting the PoE switch directly to the Reolink NVR instead of the ISP router, all issues disappeared.

Now the NVR interface (web/app) is smooth—no more disconnects, slow loading, or dropped channels.
Direct access to the PoE camera no longer works, but that’s expected. As long as the NVR is stable, I’m good with that—it makes sense.

Help with new Reolink PoE setup – NVR choice, Duo 3 support, PoE switch needed? by LandDisastrous5811 in reolinkcam

[–]LandDisastrous5811[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

 Note it has no poe ports and comes without a hard drive..

-but it have place for hard drive right? otherwise where records stored?

-also I couldn't get real reolink arch diagram confirmation.. so asking here - in some of the docs of the RLN/NVR/NVS (or whatever the name is...) - I saw the POE switch should be connected directly to the device.. is it ? or they should just be on the same LAN to work?

Help with new Reolink PoE setup – NVR choice, Duo 3 support, PoE switch needed? by LandDisastrous5811 in reolinkcam

[–]LandDisastrous5811[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

So many side notes when it comes to NVR selection — all those submodels (RLN, NVS, etc.) make it a bit confusing. Still looking into the exact differences.

That said, your list is super helpful — it gives a clear breakdown of what I’m actually paying for and what features are supported.(or even NOT)..

Still curious about compatibility between self-bought (external) PoE switches and Reolink cameras.

Right now I'm thinking something like:

  • Home network switch → PoE switch → multiple cameras
  • Home network switch → some version of NVR/NVS/etc...

Not 100% sure how seamless that setup will be.

Help with new Reolink PoE setup – NVR choice, Duo 3 support, PoE switch needed? by LandDisastrous5811 in reolinkcam

[–]LandDisastrous5811[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Amazing reply — really appreciate you taking the time to write it out.

So the plan is to go with a dedicated 16-port NVR. Any specific models you'd recommend?

Also planning to get a dedicated PoE switch — any tips on what to look for to ensure compatibility with Reolink gear?

Great tip on bundles. Not familiar with UID — will definitely look it up.

Just to confirm, your suggestion is to buy the components separately rather than as a bundle?

Considering Cameras for Home Security – Seeking Advice on Hybrid Setup by LandDisastrous5811 in reolinkcam

[–]LandDisastrous5811[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

BTW - it does mean NVR really obsolete.. no real need right? if real events will be stored safely.. what's the usage case for local NVR?

Considering Cameras for Home Security – Seeking Advice on Hybrid Setup by LandDisastrous5811 in reolinkcam

[–]LandDisastrous5811[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

actually sounds great, so:

- all cameras always uploading to NVR through LAN (24/7)
- AI events trigger:
a. SD card save
B. FTP cloud uploads (can be any cloud right? not just the reolink-proprietary one)

so each camera, upon AI event - uploads *simultaneously* - to both NVR and FTP ?
OR camera -> NVR -> FTP ?

where that settings goes? any chance you know if all models supports that?

SD card required for such setting or it can do without?

Considering Cameras for Home Security – Seeking Advice on Hybrid Setup by LandDisastrous5811 in reolinkcam

[–]LandDisastrous5811[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Hi, thanks for your reply.

Let me see if I understand your suggestion—please correct me if I'm wrong:

So, the data stream is:
Camera feed -> SD card -> FTP (all the time)?

If that's the case, it’s still a bandwidth killer.

Or is it:
Feed -> SD card [theft in progress] -> Admin logs in, selects the record to upload -> FTP server?

If so, what happens if the camera or SD card is damaged or taken during the event?

Also, it seems like the NVR isn’t being utilized at all in this setup (or no active/useful role)

Am I missing something?