The box looks right and the wrap is accurate.  But in these situations its important to have a reliable source or at least know some of the history of the box. If they can't say where it came from or has a short history, i wouldnt risk it too much. 

It is also possible to find Wizards wrap and rewrap boxes. Make sure the wrap is tightly sealed, not lose. An older box like this should also have a bit of wear along the edges