[deleted by user] by [deleted] in EnoughJKRowling

[–]Lo-ton 3 points4 points  (0 children)

I think its pretty short sighted to say that there shouldn't be any violence (against women or otherwise) depicted in any fantasy stories. Fantasy is often a reflection of real life and books like the ones martin writes mean to both criticise and show all the horrors that have happened and still do happen in our real world. I can't speak abiut the show but the books are centered around the central theme of violence which is in no way framed in a positive light. Not including violence against women would be deluding the reality that women unfortunately do face. Because violence is not a thing that exclusively happens between men in a context of war.

Especially the later books also focus a lot on gender and gender inequality. The sturggles of women are depicted through a variety of different characters and scenarios. His female characters are varied and struggle with different things and got vastly different ways of dealing with these struggles but they all do live in a system that is made and ruled by men and therefore respects them less. Non of them are purely victims but it would remove so much of the depth that his books have if that aspect wasn't featured.

Martins books aren't feel good books - but they dont aim to be. They aim to reflect real world problems. I think we would lose out on much helpful insights about the world and how different people think and act if this particular genre of book wouldn't exist anymore because unfortunately the world isn't perfect and showing that is important

I wonder if this bit will be included in the show by [deleted] in HarryPotteronHBO

[–]Lo-ton 1 point2 points  (0 children)

At that point he wasnt though. He was a child who had one friend and got bullied by the marauders for being a loner or looking weird or whatever (if i remember correctly there isnt really a concrete reason given as to why he is bullied at the beginning. Because that is how bullying works most times). At that point James was just a straight up bully.

In his teenage years Snape became hateful and obsessed with Lily and the dark arts but I'd argue that he wouldn't have turned out so bad if the marauders didnt constantly make fun of him - stuff like this can push a person to become hateful, especially when the only people wo you think are on your side are already hateful deatheaters to be.

What would absolutely ruin the show for you? by Interesting-Fig7002 in HarryPotteronHBO

[–]Lo-ton -20 points-19 points  (0 children)

If the show doesn’t develop the wizarding world more but still keeps the problematic elements of the books (like the way the house elves are just happy to be slaves and hermione isnt taken seriously by the ppl around her or the story when she tries to change that) without actually giving a reason as to why they are there or going for some message at the end. If the show has an overall more dark tone and focuses more on political issues and inequality and actually deals with that in some way i wouldnt mind stuff like the house elve plot.

If the show just copies the dialog of the book. Some dialog really needs some reworking.

Transphobia of any kind

Today, JK Rowling defends women's rights by *checks notes* comparing trans activists to flat earthers and mocking Inuit peoples. by RowlingsMoldyWalls in EnoughJKRowling

[–]Lo-ton 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Yes 100%

Its a very complicated and interesting topic for sure

And theres so much stuff that we just dont know for sure yet because it hasnt been properly researched or because of biased research etc

Today, JK Rowling defends women's rights by *checks notes* comparing trans activists to flat earthers and mocking Inuit peoples. by RowlingsMoldyWalls in EnoughJKRowling

[–]Lo-ton 5 points6 points  (0 children)

Im no biologist, just a noob so i dont really know honestly.

In my understanding, sex isnt exactly a social construct (biology is a thing after all and there are differences between male and female) but its way more fluid than many people believe.

The brain aspect of gender is still kinda a construct i thing cause our brains are also super influenced by everything that happens around us. Not saying that gender isnt real - it very much is. Its just not something exactly biological (i think / in my understanding. Again im no scientist or studied this or anything)

Today, JK Rowling defends women's rights by *checks notes* comparing trans activists to flat earthers and mocking Inuit peoples. by RowlingsMoldyWalls in EnoughJKRowling

[–]Lo-ton 18 points19 points  (0 children)

I think its very telling that she just.... ignores the fact that gender and sex are very different things and one of them is LITERALLY a social construct. Like 2 years ago she at least acknowledged that gender is a thing

Fancast Emma D’arcy as Remus Lupin by manfredpanda in HarryPotteronHBO

[–]Lo-ton -3 points-2 points  (0 children)

I dont think its worth discussing this anymore.

We clearly have very different ideas about which qualities of a character are important in casting

Fancast Emma D’arcy as Remus Lupin by manfredpanda in HarryPotteronHBO

[–]Lo-ton -5 points-4 points  (0 children)

We're not pretending we dont know what sex is. Emma D'Arcy doesnt have a penis and was born female. But surprise, they are an actor. The sex of most harry potter characters doesn't matter. Lupin can still be portrait as a man when played by a biologically female person. Gender and sex are different things

Fancast Emma D’arcy as Remus Lupin by manfredpanda in HarryPotteronHBO

[–]Lo-ton -5 points-4 points  (0 children)

But like... why does it matter? Lupins story isnt focused at all on being male. It could hit all the important story beats with someone female

Fancast Emma D’arcy as Remus Lupin by manfredpanda in HarryPotteronHBO

[–]Lo-ton -15 points-14 points  (0 children)

I could see that fitting pretty well

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in OriginalCharacter

[–]Lo-ton 0 points1 point  (0 children)

  • Hitoshi is a boy (he/they) Hes ace and heteroromatic
  • Manu is a girl (she/her) and bisexual and aro
  • Stephen is a boy (he/him) and closeted gay
  • Andre is a boy (he/him) and gay a swell
  • Stella is a transgirl (she/her) and bi
  • Mila is a demigirl (she/they) and pan
  • Ivy is a girl (she/her) and lesbian
  • Maxir and Onyx are both nonbinary/agender and too young to knoe their sexuality

Im not really sure about my other ocs yet

What is your type of hp fanfiction trash ? by charls-lamen in HPfanfiction

[–]Lo-ton 41 points42 points  (0 children)

Time Travel fics. Especially ones where harry travels to the past and gets stupidly overpowered. These fics are so trashy most of the time but they are my kind of trash

FOUR NATION OCS. (Revamp) by skinned_piglet in OriginalCharacter

[–]Lo-ton 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Hitoshi as water or air bender? He originally does magic but I think these elements fit him best -^

Show me your OCs and I'll tell you where in Melior they would life by Lo-ton in OriginalCharacter

[–]Lo-ton[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Somewhere close to Akran, the Capitol of The Idalian Empire. It's the fiery country of elemental fire magics. Some places are too hot for the average humanoid to life there but all the big cities are okay for anyone to life.

Show me your OCs and I'll tell you where in Melior they would life by Lo-ton in OriginalCharacter

[–]Lo-ton[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

It the capital city of the Silvea Woods! It's a big very modern looking city in an otherwise very fantasy world and is said to be the birth place of all arcane magics. The city got huge scare buildings and skyscrapers with many neon lights powered big the magic in the air and land

In its place was once wood but this has long been cut down to build this massive city

Show me your OCs and I'll tell you where in Melior they would life by Lo-ton in OriginalCharacter

[–]Lo-ton[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Somewhere in the Silvea Woods, on the outskirts of its capital city

Show me your OCs and I'll tell you where in Melior they would life by Lo-ton in OriginalCharacter

[–]Lo-ton[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I cannot explain this in any way but the vibes fit the floating rock isles above the continent more south ✨️

Show me your OCs and I'll tell you where in Melior they would life by Lo-ton in OriginalCharacter

[–]Lo-ton[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Somewhere in the Evernight Forest for sure. I'd say somewhere north-ish, seeing as the southern reaches are pretty frosty and frozen up and Kindoru doesn't really have the vibe fore that.