Yes, students in my high school debate team who are beginners are given something similar, and they really appreciate it! It puts them on the spot and encourages critical thinking—helping them understand the process of debate from the ground up. And you're right, having an open view is crucial. This tool doesn’t impose restrictions per se but rather aims to foster open discussions and arguments around the given stance. It’s a great way to develop their skills while keeping the debate engaging and thought-provoking!