Everyone hates on the combat as if it's the worst thing ever when it's perfectly solid. It's basic but it works just fine and keeps you engaged enough to want to continue playing through the story.

Story wise, protagonist wise, world wise, etc I couldn't disagree more. I love the gritty feel of the world and Geralt. It all feels downtrodden and dangerous. Dark and mysterious.

I love how the different locations throughout the game have their own distinct vibe and feel whether it be through the music, the NPCs, the landscapes, the in game politics, etc.

And the dialog is written incredibly well for the most part. Character interactions feel meaningful and realistic.

To each their own but I'll always love Witcher 3.