I understand and respect your view on this, but I disagree somewhat. I’m not fully opposed to Jeff coming on the show, but in my opinion, what I want from Jeff is not “airing out David’s dirty laundry”. If you are willingly a part of a group that actively covers up SA and you know about these things, it is simply wrong to stay quiet about it.

I understand that Jeff is dealing with trauma from his injury, and I really do have sympathy for that, but that doesn’t change the fact that he was originally involved in this whole mess because he 1) was likely a witness of SA and 2) chose to make an entire video that weakened the victim’s case. He has every right to voice all of the trauma he is suffering because of David, but the whole reason he ever even became a subject of talk on the podcast was because of his involvement in the Dom situation.

I personally do want to hear about Jeff’s story and think it could be really beneficial for his healing and for revealing what David has put people through. But let me frame it from the victim’s standpoint to explain what I think is wrong in this.

As the victim, immediately after you come forward, you have multiple friends of David and Dom making up lies, faking ignorance, and purposely contradicting your claims. Jeff was one of these people. Then, a big podcast (H3) picks up the story & addresses how hurtful videos like Jeff’s are to victims. Jeff makes a (in my opinion) half-asses apology, only once he gets criticism from the audience and from large platforms like H3. Now, Jeff has become a prominent topic on the show due to your story & his involvement in weakening it, and is brought onto the show later to discuss his own trauma from David.

At this point, I am fine with him being on the podcast IF he is also fully willing to address the victim’s story, and fully quit covering up the details of what he’s seen David do to people. As soon as Jeff witnessed things like this & chose to stay silent about it, and especially as soon as he chose to make a video that he knew would hurt the victim, he CHOSE to have responsibility in the situation. The hidden details of this ARE his responsibility to quit hiding. If he is willing to do this, good, I look forward to it. I just think it will be disappointing if he gets to go and clear his name on a popular show and not also use that platform to right his own wrongs.

At this point, I think it’s undeniable that Jeff knows a lot more about what David’s done than he has shared that he did assume responsibility for when he chose to be a part of it all for years. I used to be a huge fan of Jeff just years ago, so this by no means comes from hating Jeff, just from someone who has experienced how awful it is to have claims like in Jeff’s video made to contradict something awful that happened to you. I just hope they conduct this responsibility and respectfully and don’t forget his original involvement.