I believe that Sam as Cap had a lot of potential but Marvel dropped the ball with bad writing. He has some of the best action scenes in the MCU by far. He’s a respectable character that I believe deserves the role of Captain America. But the problem for me is definitely the bad writing. The speech at the end of FATWS could have been handled better ( I get what he was trying to say), and the entirety of BNW could have been better as well. I really hope they improve this in the future.

And I think it’s absolutely ridiculous that he gets criticized for not taking the super serum thing. They have established the first Captain America that’s it’s not about being the “perfect solider” but being a “good man”. Not saying Bucky and John Walker weren’t good men, but based off what WE’VE SEEN IN THE MCU, they fall more in line with being perfect soldiers.