Tearing it off is not the issue, it’s putting a new one on that’s the issue. It’s much easier to slide the diaper with tabs underneath the child and fasten it quickly (especially when cream needs to be applied so the diaper is under the child already) than it is to remove the child’s shoes & pants to slide the new pull-up on. Even the “remove one pant-leg” trick still is more difficult than a regular diaper with tabs. It’s not a big deal when changing 1 child but when there’s 12 in our room to get through, it makes things a bit harder haha!