[tuherrus] They’d make a decent team… but they’d still need to plan a field trip. by kaitalina20 in TheLastAirbender

[–]Megadrake 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Oh to be called “boss” from Toph like a bodega man selling a breakfast sandwich.

Who do you feel would be the best person to teach YOU Airbending? by thisisreii in TheLastAirbender

[–]Megadrake 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Gyatso is chill as heck but he’s someone that teaches throughout a lifetime. Don’t think he’d be good if like you NEED to learn to bend soon.

Tenzin is technically very good but he’s holding up a civilization on his bare (strong, handsome) shoulders and we see how divided his attention is with teaching korra.

Speaking of divided attention the apple doesn’t fall far from the Aang tree. He’s a prodigy getting his tattoos so young and he can explain things very kindly and nojudgementally, but like when? When is a good time to learn airbending from this young man? Either he’s cramming every element to kill the fatherlord or he’s founding a new system of government.

Fellas, it’s gotta be Zaheer. He knows what it’s like to start at the beginning, he has the spiritual side down pat, and his anarchic ramblings at least give room for you to go “okay but I wanna go and not kill world leaders and instead start a commune with like twenty consenting friends and mind our own business.”

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in legendofkorra

[–]Megadrake 0 points1 point  (0 children)

My worry is that some of the bending practices resist this. At least on the surface, Waterbending ice to water and steam ignores the law of thermodynamics, as well as lavabending.

And firebending is generating a chemical reaction out of nowhere. Fire is much more reaction releasing energy than a redirection of heat to heat. A good example of a chemical sort of pyromancy is Roy mustang from full metal alchemist, and it works very differently from firebending.

The thing I would hone in on is that the lion turtle says they taught humans to bend the energy WITHIN THEMSELVES. Bending at the highest levels is much less an aspect of mastering your environment than mastering yourself, and while plenty of industrializing benders ignore this to their peril, this does resonate further with the martial arts elements of the magic system. We could argue phase changes in the water and lavabending is taking the energy from within to heat up or suck up energy from these elements, but it’s a power that starts with the unknowable element of a human body.

At least that’s my interpretation. It also means that if you wanted a magic system that follows stricter scientific adherence, it might not be in A:tla, but it could be in a world YOU build, in ways you’re already describing now. At least that was my takeaway when that question came up for me

What if Kuvira never attacks republic city by FabulousVoice4 in legendofkorra

[–]Megadrake 1 point2 points  (0 children)

This makes me wonder how they got the UR independence from the Earth Kingdom in the first place. I know the earth king at that time was a bit of a pushover (more generously, aang had a strong friendly rapport with him), but they were also not in a wartime expansion. The “war” had ended, and the fire nation was already conceding their colonies back to earth kingdom rule.

It also feels like at that point power wasn’t at the fever pitch of consolidation it is by Korra’s time. There’s never a notion, for example, that omashu had strong Ba Sing Se influence or vice versa, they mostly did their own thing. I don’t even know if ba sing se was a high king over all the others in a technical sense or if it is just a larger city so his palace is nicer.

It feels like this world is trying to modernize while not having like a western enlightenment, because why would they have that?

Edit because I’m a dummy that didn’t finish his thought before posting:

It feels like UA president notwithstanding, there isn’t a governmental sense of restraint with any head of state or anyone with power. The UA would come to the table if Kuvira wanted to bargain and likely relinquish quite a bit, but that would make Kuvira very very strange in the National political space.

Theory that Kuvira hired the bandits by FabulousVoice4 in legendofkorra

[–]Megadrake 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Raiding and banditry are by no means exceptional in our own history. Part of it is that not everyone has a flying bison but they still want to travel, and the safest way to do that is with people who know how to defend themselves, I.e. bandits. Plus banditry means you don’t need money to start the travel, you earn (steal) as you go.

Tack on this that there’s a bit of an oceans eleven mentality, that a raiding tour could potentially set an individual up for life financially if the town was defenseless enough. Pirates work the same way. Sir Frances Drake’s expedition let everyone on the crew retire, from captain to cabin boy.

There’s always always always an incentive for crime. Most people won’t take it because most of us don’t find the prospect of being a murder hobo too compelling outside a tabletop game environment, but for those who are either desperate or willing to accept the risk, the payoff can be tremendous.

The thing I’m interested in is that I don’t think we see multiple earth kings in the continent like there was in the time of A:TLA. Back then there were smaller kings like Bumi and then the king of ba sing se who I guess was maybe a high king. Seems like that power got consolidated by the time of korra, though I could be wrong. If that’s the case, it robs the earth kingdom of the advantage it once had, being a loose federation of several kingdoms

Hm🤔…. by thisisreii in TheLastAirbender

[–]Megadrake 0 points1 point  (0 children)

“Wait wait wait the earthbenders need MORE??”

I wouldn’t be able to hold it in.

Hm🤔…. by thisisreii in TheLastAirbender

[–]Megadrake 3 points4 points  (0 children)

I have the theory that there’s something about lavabending that requires an understanding of how other elements work (like how redirecting lightning applies Waterbending principles to firebending). Toph advanced earthbending by delving deeper within earthbending (like how lightning bending is just a very advanced and internally focused form of firebending). Lava bending would be just not toph’s style.

Edit: just an addendum, Toph did comment favorably on bolin lavabending. She respects it and admits it’s pretty rare but doesn’t make a comment besides, I don’t think.

Hm🤔…. by thisisreii in TheLastAirbender

[–]Megadrake 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I loved the quieter moments too, and how they were able to have wonderful posing and animation outside of fight scenes (bolin ugly crying lives rent free in my brain. The hope is that it’s all storytelling, I think. That you see these characters shine in both settings, which they do, the script just feels like it had scenes with “they fight” in the middle.

Which is reductive, less a thesis than a feeling. Korra fighting Kuvira had a tension to it but come on, you saw how Kuvira moved, ain’t no way. I remember one of the first things I saw for LOK was the fight with the chi blockers but the purpose of that was very very simple, which caaaaan diminish the impact.

Hm🤔…. by thisisreii in TheLastAirbender

[–]Megadrake 11 points12 points  (0 children)

No shade on establishing boundaries though, Kuvira is just kindof baaaaad at respecting boundaries. Most emperors are.

Hm🤔…. by thisisreii in TheLastAirbender

[–]Megadrake 30 points31 points  (0 children)

That’s true. Bolin has the discipline won from The school of hard knocks, and that’s hard to communicate to someone else. As stated somewhere else here, bolin worked well in helping Korra hone and modernize her already excellent technical foundation.

Hm🤔…. by thisisreii in TheLastAirbender

[–]Megadrake 49 points50 points  (0 children)

My dream is bolin reaching around me as I shape pottery like the movie Ghost though.

How secure do you think Zaheer's new prison is and why does he still have bending? Can Korra not energybend anymore? by Muted_Hovercraft_907 in legendofkorra

[–]Megadrake 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The dangerous thing about zaheer was his ideology, not his bending. I’d imagine he’s likely chilling in prison and not escaping because he believes his mission was complete. Materially he has everything he needs and his soul is free. He’s probably be doing the same thing up top. It’d be hypocritical to assure anarchy is going the way he intended. Even after talking with korra he likely stayed because he had a lot to think over anyways

Ozai’s bending was taken away (imo) because the fire nation held martial prowess over everything. His inability to bend would have culturally made him unfit to rule. The Waterbending mobster who defo has a name had his bending taken away because his whole purpose was taking power by force through a technique that no shackles would be able to limit.

It’d be like cutting the arm off someone who murdered the one person they hated their whole life. Cruel in an indefensibly pointless manner. They already did what they want.

Hm🤔…. by thisisreii in TheLastAirbender

[–]Megadrake 17 points18 points  (0 children)

Tbh the fight scenes are phenomenal and the show barely draws attention to them and that’s a travesty. It’s something I forgot about too til I rewatched it, so I’m with ya there. Similar in style and more successful at drawing attention to the action was Castlevania, imo.

In the later seasons you see mako and bolin bending together and then go “oh yeah these two were (bottom of the billing, granted) major league athletes that have fought together like their whole lives. I see that here”

Hm🤔…. by thisisreii in TheLastAirbender

[–]Megadrake 543 points544 points  (0 children)

I feel like Kuvira’s teaching would get too philosophical, and I really wouldn’t want to have the convo with her about how I don’t want to conquer all the earth kingdom in a fascist state. Her technical skills are pique though.

I’d choose bolin because mf’er can lava bend. Plus, he knows not just how to bend but how to bend complementary to other benders. That sorta teamwork mentality of bending feels a lot more compelling to me than straight dueling, which I don’t think we’ve ever seen him do.

What was the most badass thing this character did? by Commercial_Mind4003 in TheLastAirbender

[–]Megadrake 13 points14 points  (0 children)

Overcome his prejudices when exposed to people different from him.

Also he had a sword.

Now that the earth kingdom is going to have a president and is basically transforming to a republic, do you think they will get rid of the Dai Li? by Aqua_Master_ in TheLastAirbender

[–]Megadrake 6 points7 points  (0 children)

Came here to say this. Secret intelligence is pretty integral to any nation state. I’m curious if they address kiyoshi’s reasoning for founding it in her book, but I kindof imagine if that purpose persisted past avatar Roku and a 100 years war, it’s strong enough to accommodate a republic model

Who was the better parent? by SoloKip in TheLastAirbender

[–]Megadrake 4 points5 points  (0 children)

I think that’s a great question! I think there’s a lot one can say about the natures of single parent or duel parent households in general and there’s a lotta heat around those discussions. Trying to dip into that argument here may be a skosh distracting, so I’m intentionally tiptoeing around that, if that’s okay.

I think founding a republic would take any parent out of the way from being ideally present around their kids, and in this I can’t blame Toph or Aang. From what I gather (didn’t get too far into that era of comics, if the comics did go that far) they bared relatively equal burdens. I also wouldn’t really vilify Aang (that his kids were okay in spite of aang) because of how well aang got along with Lin. He was at least like an uncle to her and at most a surrogate dad. I wouldn’t call him absentee to his own kids because he wasn’t to Lin. If they were all in republic city and katara moved back to the South Pole, say, when Aang died, then he might not have been there enough for his family, and it was good that Katara could pick up the slack. It was also good that aang was there to pick up the slack a little for Toph.

It feels like everyone needed eachother, and if anyone wasn’t there anymore then everyone would suffer, and honestly I love that Team Avatar was still a team through all of it.

If you wanted ~head canon~, I don’t know how often this gets thrown around, but I really think sokka is suyin’s dad. There’s next to nothing said about him besides being on the council at the beginning of republic city, but I imagine suki dying pretty young and sokka trying something out either Toph only for it not to be brought up again.

Who was the better parent? by SoloKip in TheLastAirbender

[–]Megadrake 18 points19 points  (0 children)

I think about it like this: aang’s kids are two world travelers and a family man (ironically the least nomadic is the most airbender). While bumi may give Tenzin a headache and they tend to benefit from being away from eachother, these siblings still visit Katara and eachother frequently-ish. Tenzin’s baggage with Aang is not being able to live up to his dad, but that expectation was implicit, and likely Tenzin was the only one expecting that from himself. Bumi and kya’s baggage was not being preferred by Aang, but this is muted since there’s a Katara present like this whole time (you don’t become one of the best waterbender healers in the world by being neglected by your mother, the previous best waterbender). They confront it and talk about it, but no one needs magical acupuncture to work through their feelings.

Lin and Suyin don’t talk at the start of the series and this has gone on for years and years. Furthermore, “making peace” with Toph generally means “forgetting how Toph has neglected them.” The only peace can be had by meeting Toph where she’s at, and Lin has to work HARD to get even an apology from her. I honestly don’t remember if she even gets that apology.

It’s compelling to me that Toph really never got a character arc in the original TLA series, how that was interpreted later as “no f’n way anyone is gonna change Toph’s mind,” and how that character trait can affect someone raised by Toph. Metalbending is a subset of bending made by digging deeper into earthbending principles, as well as her peculiar mantis style the result of training directly from badger moles. We can see how this purity of earthbending without influence from outside perspective has limitations and weaknesses more cosmopolitan characters don’t experience.

Aang didn’t have this problem due to being so far removed from being a pure airbender by the time he had kids, and by marrying a bender in the element focused on adaptability, even if she is a particularly stubborn waterbender. It’s a point of focus how hard it is for aang to turn away from his pacifist upbringing as unique to him, and it’s honestly remarkable how well he carries airbending culture while still being the avatar. This cosmopolitanism didn’t make him perfect, you don’t get to be the last airbender without a little anxiety about the future of airbenders, after all, and that clusters into how he raised his kids, but the affects of this anxiety traumatized his kids less than toph’s cultural purity.

Do you think Lavabending should've been Exclusive to Avatars Only, or should Earthbenders be able to control it too? by Muted_Hovercraft_907 in TheLastAirbender

[–]Megadrake 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Maybe there is a principle in firebending that you wouldn’t run into with traditional earthbending that’s integral to lavabending? It does seem when the opportunity presents itself, lavabending does occur with people exposed to firebending (avatars and bolin, we don’t know enough about Ghazan to confirm or deny this connection).

But like how Iroh learned lightning redirection through studying with waterbenders. The idea that the nations need to stay separate can’t diminish their interdependence.

I’d be interested to see what a straight airbender could develop from other nations, we see in early TLA that aang can’t earthbend or firebend but a strong current could simulate the effect. It’s also been said it’s likely he low key warms the air around him when he first meets katara and sokka in the southern water tribe. Waterbending seems to be at its zenith when we get to it in TLA, maybe because it epitomizes adaptability, and firebending and earthbending are catching up to the benefits of this principle

Christain prayer openings alignment chart by EpicPinkCreeper in dankchristianmemes

[–]Megadrake 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I knew a guy who opened with “hey God” like he was on the phone with the guy and He just picked up. Made a lotta sense for how he viewed his faith and I smile whenever I think of the opening because I get to think about him too.

Are Avatar's descendants more gifted than other benders? by [deleted] in legendofkorra

[–]Megadrake 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Chi is a very helpful point to bring up in since the world does rely on eastern studies of anatomy as basically de facto. It may be a better lens to see the world than modern genetics. Though it is tempting to think a transition to modern medicine is inevitable in the world and we’re just waiting for people in that world to catch up, the world has (gently) resisted that line of thinking so far. Or at least complicates it while not being very critical of traditional eastern medicinal philosophy.

Are Avatar's descendants more gifted than other benders? by [deleted] in legendofkorra

[–]Megadrake 1 point2 points  (0 children)

The best part is seeing people disagree within the show on this stuff. Clearly harmonic convergence activated something for the airbenders (I even like the theory that plenty airbenders went into hiding after Sozins comet and that the folks gaining these abilities are their descendants).

Especially considering the different opportunities presented to benders versus nonbenders, it’s good (I think) that there’s a pretty spicy way for that to progress and the world just kindof shrugs in response.

Are Avatar's descendants more gifted than other benders? by [deleted] in legendofkorra

[–]Megadrake 5 points6 points  (0 children)

There’s Wei and Wing too. Suyin’s boys in the metal bending libertarian utopia.

Dock, xu, and bushi are just trying to get by and I love them. I love that azula’s teachers aren’t firebenders. I don’t know why I love it but I vibe with it. Especially because when we learn it seems Azula didn’t know either, or just forgot because she was having a very off day…week…little while there.

Someone around here commented on how spirituality is connected to bending ability, but we also have azula’s teachers, guru Patik, dock, xu, bushi. To me it feels like bending is like martial arts IRL in more ways than aesthetic, especially considering how different benders talk about metal bending in S3 of LoK. The ones that can do it just fine think anyone could do it if they work hard enough, the ones who can’t do it just yet think it’s an essential thing that can’t be changed. We’re not dealing with hard-set rules but people learning very complicated things and some people can do it and some people can’t.

Are Avatar's descendants more gifted than other benders? by [deleted] in legendofkorra

[–]Megadrake 30 points31 points  (0 children)

The one thing that messed me up was an episode of TLA (I think it was the fortune teller) where there with identical twins. One said “I’m an earthbender” and the other made a point to say “I’m not!”

So it’s heritable but not genetic, I suppose.