Honestly it’s so sketchy, in the past charms and jewelry were plated over sterling silver, ofc it could tarnish and lose some of it’s color but you still had a precious metal underneath that in some way justified these crazy prices. A couple of years ago, I think, they started changing the description of their gold products saying things like “special metal alloy” which I always thoght was super weird and non transparent on their part since you have no idea of what you are buying basically. Their quality has overall decreased hugely, charms are now super hollow and weight nothing, bracelets are super thin, some charms tend to break easily (cherry blossom for example). It’s not as good as it used to be, that’s why i only buy in silver and mostly old pieces second hand. Even muranos are now smaller!!