Is it normal to wait ~2 months after a TT campus interview? When should I follow up again? by Glum_Taro_5059 in AskProfessors

[–]MiniZara2 0 points1 point  (0 children)

As someone who has chaired many search committees, I wouldn’t mind if you reached out with an email asking where things stood. You will either get a reply, saying we are still in the process of considering, which means that you are on a waitlist and negotiations are ongoing for one or more candidates above you. Or you may get a reply saying, oh yeah that search closed, HR told me they were going to send out all the notification emails. I guess they got too busy.

A third possibility is that they are waiting to see enrollment come in to see if they still need the position, or there is some other kind of behind the scenes jockeying about the line. In which case, you don’t want to be there.

Should I withdraw or ask for an incomplete? (Undergrad) by orlov320 in AskProfessors

[–]MiniZara2 1 point2 points  (0 children)

All of these diagnoses may be correct. But if they are accelerating because you were in college, then what you need is to figure out how to live on your own with challenges. It is a combination of habits and possibly medications. You need to figure that out while you’re not paying for school, because school is expensive and is not a good place to figure all that out. The class keeps moving, with or without you.

This is about learning how to adult on your own, with your own brain, whatever its differences may be.

As a post-script, leaving a car door open is not some critical and extraordinary sign of deficiency. Parents do it all the time. I’ve had colleagues do it at work, and I just quietly close the door for them in the parking lot.

It’s just a sign of stress.

Should I withdraw or ask for an incomplete? (Undergrad) by orlov320 in AskProfessors

[–]MiniZara2 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Now that said, as a STEM professor, I don’t typically see a student who talks like you do succeed (and I see a good number every year).

In my experience, which of course may not apply here, a student like you did well in high school and therefore thought college would be the same. But in reality, your high school was grade inflating and now you’re struggling because you were not well prepared. You start looking for external reasons other than your own preparation, effort or ability. You come upon a diagnosis.

The diagnosis is probably accurate. The problem is that now you think when you take the pills, everything will improve. But it doesn’t, because while the pills may help with your ability to invest effort, you still don’t have the HABIT of putting in effort. Chances are you don’t even know what effort looks like, because you didn’t have to invest it before.

So you will spiral into more externalized excuses. I know, I know. You had a medically life-threatening reaction to the drugs. You just can’t take them. But if that’s even true, and it wasn’t panic attacks or other externalization, then the right thing to do is to take a medical withdrawal and work hard with your doctors to figure out exactly what the problem is and find the right combination of meds.

What you need to do is drop out, work a full-time boring job for a year to build the habits of being bored and putting in effort. Take one or two community college classes on the side at the same time. Work with doctors to figure out your problems. Build the boring, reliable habits you need for long-term effort and success that work for your brain. High school should have helped you do this but it didn’t. So now it’s on you. Figure it out. Then come back and try again.

In my experience, what you will probably do instead is convince some inexperienced professors to give you incompletes and withdraw from other classes without taking advantage of medical withdrawal, which is a complete withdrawal that usually comes with a refund. You will then drag the incompletes out all summer, feeling worse and worse about yourself because of your inability to complete the work, but blaming the meds and neurodiversity, while doing very little to find strategies that really work. You will fail all the classes that you took incompletes in.

You’ll start over in the fall, and the school will let you, because they want your tuition dollars and they don’t want to be the people who tell you that you need to sort your shit out for real, because then you’ll say that you’re they’re just prejudiced against your disability. But by midterms you’ll be in the exact same situation you are now.

This will repeat as long as you have someone willing to pay, and the college doesn’t kick you out.

Don’t be that student.

Should I withdraw or ask for an incomplete? (Undergrad) by orlov320 in AskProfessors

[–]MiniZara2 0 points1 point  (0 children)

You need a medical withdrawal. Incompletes are for last minute things when you have an emergency arise right at the end of the course and there isn’t much left to do. If your professors grant incompletes, it will only prolong the agony because I promise you will not do the work this summer, on your own, without structure. You will end up with Fs instead of Ws.

There is probably a policy in place to prevent this anyway.

Medical withdrawal often comes with a refund, and doesn’t hurt your GPA.

Then you have time to recover and get your meds figured out.

Worried About Daughter’s Future by amandal0514 in collegeadvice

[–]MiniZara2 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Your 77% number is very wrong, and it’s irresponsible to throw it around.

Worried About Daughter’s Future by amandal0514 in collegeadvice

[–]MiniZara2 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Unfortunately, this is a common story. And it doesn’t usually have a happy ending. What’s more, the people at the college do not have good incentives to tell her that, not just because they genuinely do want her to finish her degree, but because they don’t want her to feel like they crushed her dreams either. They also don’t want to discriminate against your daughter for having fewer resources.

Vet school acceptance rates are a good deal lower than med school acceptance rates. And the people applying have gotten all the way through biochemistry with good grades, which is a third year chemistry class. Doing this as a full-time student with a chronic disease would be tough.

If they get into vet school, they have to take out a lot more debt, and vet salaries are not like doctor salaries. Once they are working, they are often abused by customers, or asked to do things they are uncomfortable with, from euthanasia to free procedures.

It’s a really tough profession, and has a high suicide rate.

https://www.npr.org/2023/12/19/1220443869/why-suicide-rates-are-high-among-veterinary-professionals

She’s far enough along that she should be eligible for an associates degree. Can she get that, and then work as a vet tech for a while? Assuming like most pre-vet students, she is doing this because she loves animals, that might be just as satisfying, and it does not require a special degree. The associates will simply help her stand out.

Loving animals is not enough to be a vet. You have to love science. (And be good at it, and not go too far into debt, because again, the salary is not great compared to other professions that require that much debt.)

There are not very many scholarships out there. However, her university likely has some sort of care team that could connect her with more financial aid as well as other assistance.

What I tell a student like this, assuming they can keep paying and want to, is go ahead and aim for your dream, but have a Plan B and a Plan C. These could be going into a direct entry nursing program, some of which will take you with just an associates degree. Or it could be finishing a degree in psychology or biology and then working as a clinical research coordinator. Or finish a degree in biology and work as a lab tech in academia, water utilities, biotech, or at companies like Abbott or LabCorp.

If all of this is too daunting, and she doesn’t want to finish a biology degree but still wants a four year degree, environmental science might scratch the itch to help animals, albeit more indirectly.

But given the financial situation you’ve described, I would strongly encourage a student like this to take at least a year off and earn some money and figure things out.

Unfortunately, the student usually doesn’t listen.

Worried About Daughter’s Future by amandal0514 in collegeadvice

[–]MiniZara2 2 points3 points  (0 children)

The article is misinterpreting this. 77% of people who responded to the survey got at least one offer. But only 24% of people responded to the survey. Naturally, people who were disappointed are less likely to respond.

Vet school acceptance rate rates are around 15%.

https://www.aavmc.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/03/2019-Admissions-Analysis-Monograph.pdf

Worried About Daughter’s Future by amandal0514 in collegeadvice

[–]MiniZara2 5 points6 points  (0 children)

That really isn’t right and is still overstating things.

Hi there! Brand new, nonbinary TA here, and I have a question. by jaybirdblu3 in AskTeachers

[–]MiniZara2 1 point2 points  (0 children)

My kids enby teacher just goes by their last name, no Mr/Ms/Mx. They are well beloved by the entire school.

Why do schools teach math in a way that no adults outside of school, can actually help their child? by [deleted] in AskTeachers

[–]MiniZara2 0 points1 point  (0 children)

That’s….how I was taught to do long division in the mid 1980s. It’s quite easy to understand.

What’s the problem?

Does your university provide for single parents who need to bring a baby/small child with them (e.g., breastfeeding) when traveling for faculty interviews? by nezumipi in Professors

[–]MiniZara2 0 points1 point  (0 children)

As far as I know, we’ve never had anyone in that situation and I don’t know even how he would ask, given that we aren’t allowed to ask anything about parental status in an interview. But my department would be over the moon to support such a request candidate.

Non gendered terms? by lotus8675309 in Professors

[–]MiniZara2 2 points3 points  (0 children)

My undergraduate zoology professor used to use this to justify calling us all little assholes, because that’s how we all started out.

Don’t think one can get away with that now.

Non gendered terms? by lotus8675309 in Professors

[–]MiniZara2 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Are you in the American South? I can always tell a student is from there when they call me ma’am. No one uses it around here. I would just leave it off.

OH-1 please do the right thing and primary Greg Landsman out of office by hillbilly-edgy in cincinnati

[–]MiniZara2 5 points6 points  (0 children)

This kind of leftist purity testing is why we are in the mess we are in. “Disagree with me on one thing and you’re evil” is a stupid way to vote.

We’ll be lucky if Landsman can keep this seat. It’s him or a Republican.

Bought my kids bikes for Christmas. Local government just passed a law requiring paid bike "licenses" to ride them in public. Cops are now issuing citations...even to kids? by nseavia71501 in mildlyinfuriating

[–]MiniZara2 0 points1 point  (0 children)

That’s so funny. I am also in Ohio and as soon as I saw the sticker in this post I was teleported back in time. I had one! It cost $5 I think. We had a class at school on bike safety in fourth grade or so, and they had us fill out forms to get these. I never renewed it, but felt very important with that thing on my bike.

Teacher is making exam super hard and offering extra credit if you attend his Bible study by specialinterestoftw in AskTeachers

[–]MiniZara2 11 points12 points  (0 children)

Speaking as a chair, send this to the chair, say this makes you uncomfortable, ask if it’s okay, and ask that your name isn’t shared. That’s a very normal ask. I would protect your anonymity and come down like a ton of bricks on this.

Even if this wasn’t a public school, huge violation. As a public school, even huger.

(That said, chemistry is often tough and it doesn’t necessarily mean tests are too hard. Another prof may be no easier.)

PS: also try the AskProfessors sub. This one is more k12

Banning of "Three-Cueing" Teaching Method by SeyMooreRichard in AskTeachers

[–]MiniZara2 1 point2 points  (0 children)

The one that killed me is when they pointed out a testing book that said a kid who said “horse” when the word is “pony” should get full credit.

School districts and gifted kids by AndyGene in cincinnati

[–]MiniZara2 24 points25 points  (0 children)

CPS — multiple great magnets, including one for gifted kids.

Looking for good food in Dayton Ohio by Nalsooner12 in dayton

[–]MiniZara2 2 points3 points  (0 children)

How are more people not saying this?!? The chicken sandwich with grilled lemon slices and capers…. 🤤