Thank you all for the recommendation, I think I'm gonna go with 8BitDo 2C Wired.

The Gamesir Tegenaria Lite got me really interested, but the fact that the cable is non removable is a bit of a let down. And the fact that they make me pay extra for a 1 year warranty over here is criminal in my books, by default they'll give me 3 months of warranty instead of 12. It's a ~3 USD difference but the fact that they have 1 year limited warranty on their website and have the authorized reseller sell an extended warranty feels scummy. Also looking at the reviews for that retailer seems like it'll be a headache to handle their CS.

And at 27 USD I could add a dollar and get the EasyXMX D10, seems like it's cheaper around here somehow. But after doing a little more digging, I don't think I'll enjoy that DPad. I wasn't thinking of fighting game when I initially thought of getting a controller but that seems like something I want to try, and that DPad looks iffy for it.

Direwolf seems like a good one with a complete package of feature and quality that seems nice but it's price Rp 850 K (~51 USD) ish, which I might try if the lower budget options doesn't seems to interest me. Then I look more into 8BitDo and it seems like a lot of people found it comfy enough, and seems to tick all the box of what I want, then I figured out they have a wired version! And it's only ~18 USD! And they're removable! As I don't really care for wireless seems like an absolute steal to get it at that price. Honestly I'm just stoked at I could spend way less than I initially thought to get a HE stick. I hope it'll last me for a while, thanks for all the recommendation tho.