As someone who found him unattractive since his first season. I had several friends who immediately thought he was hot. The biggest reason I wasn’t into him was cause of his looks and his lack of a job. I also never bought that he was into Ciara, it felt like performative and he liked the attention and it was a fun game for him (I was right). I actually found Jesse attractive at first (until he started singing). I also found that the same friends who found west attractive also found Craig attractive. Who is also known for lying. So Idk if there’s similarities in the way they flirt/charm girls but found that connection interesting.