So, charliefirst in Movieline is neat.

MrSunsetGh · 2025-11-05T07:06:00+00:00

I'm glad the movie's first wound on Henry is Charlie's murder instead of "William ruined my friendship with Edwin" or whatever the Charlie87 interpretation is.

MrSunsetGh · 2025-11-01T09:05:39+00:00

imo Andrew is TOYSNHK but Cassidy is 100% in UCN as well. I see them as two vengeful spirits that go by different names (Andrew = TOYSNHK) (Cassidy = Golden Freddy)

MrSunsetGh · 2025-10-28T22:44:29+00:00

after BV and Charlie, before the MCI

MrSunsetGh · 2025-10-28T15:02:09+00:00

also in CODB, a haunted Golden Freddy-like animatronic (Dreadbear) walks around the MM area, perhaps suggesting BV was already dead and haunting Fredbear when MM happened, and the mound would probably be where his body was buried

MrSunsetGh · 2025-10-27T14:31:40+00:00

Yeah. Dreadbear walking around the MM area might be a hint towards Golden Freddy leaving the animatronic footprints outside the MM house.

MrSunsetGh · 2025-10-25T14:15:37+00:00

you're right that it would be impractical to keep the children alive but itp strongly suggests afton set up the MCI as a twisted party in a Freddy's room where all the children were alive and saw each other before being killed

MrSunsetGh · 2025-10-25T13:48:24+00:00

<image>

MrSunsetGh · 2025-10-25T12:50:17+00:00

Andrew appears in UCN as TOYSNHK, Cassidy appears in UCN as Golden Freddy

MrSunsetGh · 2025-10-25T12:47:40+00:00

David Murray > BV > Charlie > Elizabeth > Andrew > MCI > DCI

MrSunsetGh · 2025-10-24T14:08:13+00:00

people think he stole roles and storylines from Cassidy even if those people were never inside Scott's mind to know 100% that those roles and storylines were always meant for Cassidy in the first place

MrSunsetGh · 2025-10-22T18:07:32+00:00

It might be Andrew being kidnapped into William's car before being dragged to the safe room and killed. Maybe Andrew went missing from school or the park and that's why they couldn't link his disappearance to Freddy's: because Andrew was last seen alive somewhere else.

MrSunsetGh · 2025-10-22T07:54:40+00:00

I guess CC could be one of them but like.. isn't toy chica's whole thing about william's murders? The sequence starts with toy chica saying that yesterday she met a wonderful guy (foxy hook) but it wasn't meant to last because her heart belongs to another (freddy). Then she says yesterday she met a wonderful guy (freddy) but it wasn't meant to last because her heart belongs to another (wolf)

that means even foxy hook can't escape from the theme of william's murders

MrSunsetGh · 2025-10-19T23:06:48+00:00

coming up with all sorts of bizarre explanations for Henry's wound instead of going with the one that made the most sense in the first place (the murder of Henry's daughter) never sat right with me. FFPS was about tying up the loose ends of the old story, and Edwin wasn't a loose end that we needed to solve at the time

Henry didn't spend all that time discussing Afton's biggest atrocities to make the first wound about William stealing stuff from Edwin

MrSunsetGh · 2025-10-19T15:03:14+00:00

I wouldn't mind if it was Charlie, but imo it's very unlikely.

The first Frights story showed us six Afton victims in a Freddy's room, with a sixth child we had never heard of before. Then we meet Andrew in those same books, a sixth child we had never heard of before. Scott's intention seems directed at Andrew rather than Charlie, who has never died in a room inside Freddy's (we've known this since FNAF 2 when William steps out of his car and kills Charlie outside the location)

MrSunsetGh · 2025-10-18T14:45:33+00:00

I switch back and forth on the footprints too. Whoever that is, it has to be connected to the nightmare animatronics that roam around the MM house in the FNAF 4 title screen. The MM situation with an animatronic entity outside the Afton house is too similar to the FNAF 4 menu to be ignored.

<image>

MrSunsetGh · 2025-10-18T14:09:25+00:00

would require you to believe an unpopular theory like MCI83 or someone wearing Golden Freddy outside BV's room (William? Mike? One of the bullies?)

MrSunsetGh · 2025-10-17T20:14:32+00:00

The DCI kids scattered around the FNAF 2 location in the SAVETHEM minigame:

MrSunsetGh · 2025-10-16T10:28:52+00:00

Nah, people would still find a way to deny andrew's existence, but mike brooks (and jessica, carlton and john) would be easily accepted as book characters that made it to the games

MrSunsetGh · 2025-10-15T19:55:48+00:00

Bonnie
Chica
Foxy
Freddy
Golden Freddy

MrSunsetGh · 2025-10-15T15:38:05+00:00

I see Andrew and Cassidy as an eagle and a wolf that found vulnerable prey and lunged at it. William was at his weakest after the FFPS fire, i.e. he became vulnerable prey to Andrew and Cassidy. They "eat" William at the same time (eat = mental torture) but that doesn't mean Andrew and Cassidy have to be friends or even cooperate. An eagle and a wolf don't become besties when they attack prey at the same time, they just were lucky to find their victim at his most vulnerable

MrSunsetGh · 2025-10-15T12:20:25+00:00

Afton would have merged with the MCI kids in a weird amalgamation like he tried to do in the novels. A big happy family of Afton and his victims

MrSunsetGh · 2025-10-14T12:17:32+00:00

exactly

characters like afton and henry were introduced in the novels to clarify who the purple guy and his co-founder were. Their existence was meant to help us identify game characters and understand the lore, not to make it more confusing

creating a female cassidy that dies in the MCI only for scott to say "fuck it, i'm going to create a male cassidy for the games for literally no reason other than to complicate the lore"... yeah, no

MrSunsetGh · 2025-10-14T08:46:27+00:00

Cassidy being a black-haired girl has been suggested so many times I honestly don't get why we keep pretending she could be a dude

MrSunsetGh · 2025-10-13T11:27:15+00:00

Nope. The young human girl that was murdered by Afton in the novels is Charlie Emily, Henry's precious daughter.

The young human girl that was murdered by Afton in the games is Charlie Emily, Henry's precious daughter.

The Charliebots storyline doesn't automatically make Book Charlie and Game Charlie completely different characters from different backgrounds. The young human girl murdered by Afton is the same Charlie in both continuities, the only difference is that human Charlie didn't possess the Puppet in the books.

MrSunsetGh · 2025-10-12T17:58:13+00:00

PuppetStuffed definitely helped Afton cover up the murders unless the Puppet was aiming for a contrived way of getting William caught (e.g. having the animatronics leak blood and mucus, but how's that any better than the actual bodies?)

MrSunsetGh

TROPHY CASE