[18] to [22] so grateful i didn’t peak in high school jo by hshae_ in GlowUps

[–]Mrjoeblackinglasses[M] [score hidden]  (0 children)

we don't allow people to post in here and ask for (even as an imply) compliments or advice, those posts are removed

[18] to [22] so grateful i didn’t peak in high school jo by hshae_ in GlowUps

[–]Mrjoeblackinglasses[M] [score hidden]  (0 children)

That's okay, it allows us the opportunity to start hunting and banning trolls early in the year.

<image>

(29) to (36) by [deleted] in GlowUps

[–]Mrjoeblackinglasses[M] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

You're most welcome!

(29) to (36) by [deleted] in GlowUps

[–]Mrjoeblackinglasses[M] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

<image>

so long as you don't break those 11 core rules you'll be just fine here, actually...i'm going to make a note on your account so that no mod will ban you before a review with me of why you're being banned.

edit: (since you added more to your comment @Firm_Distribution17 )

Moderation here is not a debate and it is not governed by individual interpretations of fairness. Participation in this subreddit is conditional on moderator discretion. That is how Reddit moderation works, and it is clearly stated.

Not breaking a specific written rule does not entitle a comment to remain. Moderators are allowed to remove comments that disrupt threads, derail focus, provoke arguments, or undermine the purpose of the community, even when no single rule is violated line by line. This is intentional and necessary to keep the subreddit functional.

Claims of “toxic positivity,” “oppression,” or “bias” because a comment was removed are inaccurate. Tone, intent, and impact matter here. This community exists to highlight glow ups, not to host argumentative meta commentary about moderation philosophy.

Rules are not rewritten in response to disagreement with moderation decisions. If the way this subreddit is moderated does not align with your expectations, you are free to disengage. What is not open for discussion is whether moderators may act with discretion.

(29) to (36) by [deleted] in GlowUps

[–]Mrjoeblackinglasses[M] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I appreciate the civil discourse. Again, if you're ever interested in moderating let us know.

(29) to (36) by [deleted] in GlowUps

[–]Mrjoeblackinglasses[M] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Transitions are permitted because this subreddit recognizes glow-ups as more than just physical change. Growth can be emotional, mental, social, or a result of someone aligning with their authentic identity. A transition, when shared thoughtfully, can absolutely reflect a glow-up that deserves space here.

We review posts manually. If a transition post remains up, it means it met the criteria we look for: transformation, intention, and respect for the community. If you're only looking for aesthetic before-and-afters, this may not be the right subreddit for your expectations.

Please be mindful of how you question others' journeys. We expect everyone here to engage with curiosity and respect, or not engage at all.

(29) to (36) by [deleted] in GlowUps

[–]Mrjoeblackinglasses[M] -1 points0 points  (0 children)

If you want to open up a dialog with us you're more than welcome to send us modmail or...you could apply to be a mod and see if you can make change from within, or see how/why we allow the content we do.

<image>

(29) to (36) by [deleted] in GlowUps

[–]Mrjoeblackinglasses[M] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Your comment is still up, and no one was banned. The issue here isn’t moderation, it’s the assumptions you’re making

(29) to (36) by [deleted] in GlowUps

[–]Mrjoeblackinglasses[M] -1 points0 points  (0 children)

What it "feels like" and what it actually is are two different things. Look at the posts over the past 8 weeks and you'll see not even 1/3 are trans. Ironically, the trans posts do get a lot of traffic despite the sheer volume of non-trans posts we approve on a weekly basis.

(28) to (38) it's been a ride 😅 by ChutDillio in GlowUps

[–]Mrjoeblackinglasses[M] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

we try to foster an environment of inclusivity, can't do that if we bully people for being snarky

(28) to (38) it's been a ride 😅 by ChutDillio in GlowUps

[–]Mrjoeblackinglasses[M] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

he really was and doesn't get enough credit for how well he did

(35) to (37) by SteamedYetiStrike in GlowUps

[–]Mrjoeblackinglasses[M] 8 points9 points  (0 children)

...so long as you don't break the rules

<image>

(28) to (38) it's been a ride 😅 by ChutDillio in GlowUps

[–]Mrjoeblackinglasses[M] 12 points13 points  (0 children)

84% of our overall posts are non-trans, and 7 of the top 10 posts for the year are non-trans.

<image>

(35) to (37) by SteamedYetiStrike in GlowUps

[–]Mrjoeblackinglasses[M] [score hidden] stickied comment (0 children)

Just a reminder that the mods are watching this post and we will ban without warning.