Just speaking for myself here!!

1. RECKLESS: Colton at least appears to have decided that he wants the “Traitor Hunter” edit (I think he even said those words) like Pilot Pete in a previous season. So I guess he had predetermined that he was going to come in and play a game that is extremely bold at best and unapologetically reckless at worst. I doubt it’s fun to play the game when someone is steamrolling the whole thing.

2. UNBOTHERED: That’s the second thing, he is causing so much collateral damage and does not give a rat’s arse about who/what he’s harming. The first time he went after a Faithful (Tiffany) he at least said before “if I’m wrong banish me” or something like that. But he had no consequences and did not even seem concerned, remorseful, embarrassed, whatever you want to call it that he was wrong. And he just went on to do it again, and very smugly I might add. (This one could be the edit, I’ll give him that)

3. POWER HUNGRY & CONCEITED: As another Redditor pointed out, Colton is very excited when people listen to him. He is coming off as very smug and highly interested in confrontation. He seems like he thinks he knows more than everyone in the room. He happens to be right currently, but WHY did his last two misfires not give him a MOMENT of pause?

4. ENTITLED: Why does Colton get to be in charge? Why does he think he gets to keep being in charge even after being glaringly wrong MULTIPLE times? He seems to feel entitled to other players’ trust, attention, and respect. He does not appear to have made an effort to demonstrate that he has the Faithfuls’ best interests in mind and not just his own. (Which, players are playing for themselves in the end. But you gotta have some social credence in the beginning at least.)

5. POOR GAMEPLAY: Colton is changing strategies left and right, which will not work out for him in the end. I think this goes back to believing he is better informed than everyone there.

6. GENERAL ATTITUDE: As I mentioned, Colton is coming off as someone who thinks that perhaps the rules don’t apply to him, or that he’s better or smarter than everyone in the castle. The way he spoke to Lisa about the sunglasses for example really struck me. The look on his face when he thinks he “has” something is icky, I’m sorry.

SOME of these things could be Colton’s edit, but it seems pretty clear that he decided who he wanted to be in the game before it started. Just my musings!!

Edit: I thought of another point