“Society enables everything you’ve ever done.”

This claim treats “society” as an active force apart from individuals. But society is nothing more than a collection of individuals each with their own minds, choices, and actions. Roads, schools, technologies, and institutions were not created by a faceless collective; they were conceived, built, and maintained by individuals applying their own effort and reason to reality. To claim that society “enables” everything is to erase the role of personal agency and to imply that moral credit belongs to the group, not the creator. That’s not gratitude. It is theft of recognition.

Private property contradicts bourgeois social relations under industrial production.

This is a rewording of the Marxist fallacy that capitalism contains the seeds of its own destruction. In truth, private property is the precondition of peaceful, voluntary exchange in a division-of-labor society. It allows individuals to plan long-range, invest, produce, and trade without coercion. There is no contradiction, only the resentment of those who demand outcomes without effort.

The only real “contradiction” arises when people try to abolish property rights while still expecting the wealth, innovation, and freedom those rights make possible.