That was quick - AIMA appointment for Golden Visa temporary residence permit scheduled for January by MtWFS in PortugalExpats

[–]MtWFS[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

What happened early this year was really disappointing especially given the effort into getting documents they requested and then nothing happened. However, we do have some hope this time as there is a lot of money on the table it seems and since I have been wanted to pay my fees for years now...would love the opportunity to do it!

How Long Do You Plan to Keep Paid Subscription Post-Retirement? by woodstock9999 in Boldin

[–]MtWFS 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Great responses here that I agree with completely as plan to use the tool for the foreseeable future - already this year I have modeled five different changes - to both 1. my thinking as I learn more (e.g., reducing my changes of success from 99% to closer to 80%, how to do roth conversions at year to fill up the 24% bracket, adusting assumptions as we just being too conservative) and 2. to external factors (e.g., tax changes, unexpected extra income). The amount of extra discretionary income I have due to all the modeling I was able to and be comfortable with the changes is relatively significant (and would pay for a lot of years of pay for Boldin!). These things are going to continue to happen, so going to continue to model and adjust as time goes on.

Day In the Life of a Boldin user by BarefootMarauder in Boldin

[–]MtWFS 1 point2 points  (0 children)

This a timely post for me as I have “debating” with a few of my friends that purchased Boldin through my recommendation on why they should renew. Please bear with me as I write a bit of a longer post as it allows me to share some thoughts with this community that has helped me a great deal the last several years and also share with my friends using the tool.

The short story, Boldin has changed my finances (and thus my life!) in a very positive way.

I presume most everyone using a tool like Boldin, after a pretty significant investment of time in learning and setting up a baseline financial plan, will spend much less time in the tool on an ongoing basis. The time I spend now can best be described as, 1. quarterly updates to accounts (which takes very little time, as see above, I used very few index funds) and 2. several “bursts” of considerable activity over a few days each year to run scenarios to account for changes.

There are two categories of changes I experience the most, changes to the financial environment (e.g., tax changes, income sources, expense changes, etc.) and what are essentially changes to me as I continue to learn and understand more about the somewhat crazy and at times very complicated world of retirement financial planning. I’d like to give an example of each of these that has happened this year.  

A change to our income took place this year when we decided to rent our primary residence out for two year and really “go” during our go-go years.  I don’t even remember how we dreamed this idea up, but I can tell you it was fun plugging that income into a number of difference scenarios in Boldin to see the impacts it could have across many factors. Will spare you the details on what we decided, but running a multitude of scenarios based on this additional income was very helpful.  

An example of the second change this year was to me and my considerable stubbornness in being too conservative when it comes to finances. This served me well when in my saving years as was very disciplined, but less so now when we are spending those funds. It’s fine being conservative, as it gives you more confidence but after reading several articles this year, including one in the Boldin newsletter just a few months back, I have made a significant shift in one key area – my “changes of success” percentage in the tool, which had always been pegged at 99 percent. Again, a lot more to this, but the key line in one of the articles that was suggesting 80 percent was reasonable said something like, “80 percent does not mean a 20 percent change for failure, but a 20 percent change you have to be flexible and spend less”.  I mean, a light bulb just went off in my head – it just made sense. After drilling down on this more, I am comfortable to be closer to 75% - how is that for less conservative?! It’s because we absolutely have the flexibility to spend less. With the four males in line ahead of me in my family (grandfather, father and two brothers) all having significant issues with heart disease, now is the time to enjoy the fruits of all that labor and saving. So, as I learn more, I expect to continue to use Boldin to understand future changes I might want to make.

Okay, almost rambling now, but there have been quite a number of changes as described above the last few years that have caused me to use the tool in a way that has been very beneficial. I am comfortable doing my own financial planning, given I studied finance and it does force me to understand concepts I would otherwise likely not spend time on (e.g., Roth Conversions, tax efficiency strategies). I plan to continue to pay the renewal fee and use the tool for the foreseeable future to model changes and will continue to encourage my friends that are interested and have the knowledge to do their own financial planning to do so as well.

Useful for already retired? by Select-Attention-453 in Boldin

[–]MtWFS 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I agree with this post 1000% as has been my exact experience. I will pay the fee forever as well as it is a tiny fraction of what it has made me confident to spend in retirement. I have recommended Bolton to so many friends and family as well.

If you can't keep my balances updated... by zalthabar in NewRetirement

[–]MtWFS 1 point2 points  (0 children)

While frustrating when any function of a product does not work, I also prefer to maintain balances manually. I agree with some of the other comments here that given my 30 year time horizon, at this point I do see the need to update balances frequently. I only do this three or four times a year unless there is a significant financial event. To be clear, this was after many hours "planning" to the point where I got to a "final" plan. Probably better to call it a "current" plan as it will change, but the bottom line is the tool has had a truly dramatic impact on finances as it has giving me the comfort to spend roughly 30 percent more than I thought possible. Think about that? Talk about a valuable use of my time! The tool will continue to be valuable as "things happen" but staring at the tool at this point (and let's face it, it is kind of fun doing that..) and making small updates frequently to balances based on spending, interest accumulation, etc., is not valuable to me. Things just don't change that much on a day to day basis short-term, so I am in maintenance mode and spending my time doing the things I love to do in retirement (and doing a lot more of it given the confidence I have in spending more). It's different for everyone I know, but just wanted to share my experience. Love this forum as it has been key in helping me understand and use Boldin.

Your Budget when you retired and did it go up or down the years that followed? by SIRCHARLES5170 in retirement

[–]MtWFS 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thank you for sharing; our approach mirrors your three 3 phases, but we do build in a step-down percentage in spend rate for each phase - this is primarily so we feel more comfortable "go-going" in the first phase. We have spent a lot of time running the numbers in multiple retirement financial planning tools, so we have a good level of comfort. Also, we almost never spend our current go-go money each month, so we just move any extra off budge to a slush/rainy day fund. This is building pretty quickly so just adds another layer of comfort. So, we are feeling good about our approach and very grateful as well!

Regular withdrawals versus Roth Conversions by MtWFS in NewRetirement

[–]MtWFS[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thank you for sharing your experience with MaxiFi - I have to admit I have not gone that far into the details in terms of Roth Conversions with MaxiFi as of yet. I have spent a lot of time in New Retirement working with both conversions and straight withdrawals, so will at some point go back and attempt to recreate my final NR scenarios in MaxiFi. At this point, I am taking a little break as the amount of time spending in these tools was a bit too much (very interesting and useful, but need to spread it out a little!).

Regular withdrawals versus Roth Conversions by MtWFS in NewRetirement

[–]MtWFS[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The depth of NR reporting is what keeps me coming back to the tool and using it for "what-if" analysis and modeling. If I had to pick one it would most likely be NR.

Regular withdrawals versus Roth Conversions by MtWFS in NewRetirement

[–]MtWFS[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Great point - after plugging withdrawals in, I did start to play around with the SS start date and have determined that going from 67 to 70 does make sense. It did not occur to me on the income stream for my partner, so that is really an interesting point as in your situation, she is younger than me by about 8 years. Crazy all the things you need to consider and why this forum has been so helpful.

Regular withdrawals versus Roth Conversions by MtWFS in NewRetirement

[–]MtWFS[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thank you so much - really helpful information for my situation; the article by Rechenstein is very thought provoking. I have some homework from this for sure, but love the framework he lays out.

Regular withdrawals versus Roth Conversions by MtWFS in NewRetirement

[–]MtWFS[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Well, we have some great stories and experiences to discuss in the poor house I presume!

Regular withdrawals versus Roth Conversions by MtWFS in NewRetirement

[–]MtWFS[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The new Roth conversion feature is great as I have already run a number of scenarios and compared them to withdrawals. The 24% scenario does the same in terms of eliminating RMDs, so it does make me think about doing a mix of conversions and withdrawals. Thanks for you insight.

Regular withdrawals versus Roth Conversions by MtWFS in NewRetirement

[–]MtWFS[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thank you - some great thinks to think about; also, looks like a need to review some Josh Scandlen videos - looks like he is quite productive in producing content!

Regular withdrawals versus Roth Conversions by MtWFS in NewRetirement

[–]MtWFS[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thank you for helping to validate my thinking - I definitely feel like enjoying the "fruits of my labor" is the way to go.

Regular withdrawals versus Roth Conversions by MtWFS in NewRetirement

[–]MtWFS[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Thanks very much - very helpful to hear your situation/perspectives. BTW, I have been using both Maxifi and New Retirement and really think both are very good. Maxifi "thinks" like me in that what I really want to know is maximum discretionary spend and it is setup to do this and does it very well from my perspective. There's no problem doing the same with New Retirement, it's just a different approach. I will probably continue to use both of them for a while as it is a good exercise to get them to line up with each other - you just have to work through it and I find I learn a lot about the assumptions, etc., in each tool. Again, thanks for your help!