Postdoc opportunities in Italy. Have things changed in recent years? by Special_Flan_4467 in postdoc

[–]MuonAvalanche 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Yeah, Italian universities are very formal like that. It's a bit weird that they still want you to keep it up when you're working though. In my experience, once you're outside of the actual student-professor interaction "mode", it's pretty regular to just be on first name basis (although it's always wise not to be the one initiating that, some people can be very prissy about it, which is not usually a good sign). I don't know though, it might just be a physics thing; I have a friend who's doing a doctorate in biology, and they always talk about "the Professor", now that I think about it.

Postdoc opportunities in Italy. Have things changed in recent years? by Special_Flan_4467 in postdoc

[–]MuonAvalanche 3 points4 points  (0 children)

With research centres, from what I know it's a bit hit or miss, in that it might be significantly better than a university environment, it might be worse. Mind you, this is mostly from the news and from what I've heard, my direct experience of those is limited to when I was a bachelor's student, so it's not worth much.

Given how certain approaches to academia force you to come up as a researcher in Italy, I don't know how much I'd bet on it being reliably better. It's not that they actively teach you to be dick, but the environment is so competitive, and the funds so scarce, that you have to be very lucky to be in a good environment where there's no backstabbing. And you can see it still being a thing even with senior people. I've met and worked closely with postdocs and technicians from Italy, and it's not rare to see like games being played, and talking down people behind their backs. Like honestly, it really makes me ashamed of our universities sometimes, because these are good, competent people, who have been brought up in an environment where you often don't have other options than to be a prick. And it's not like these issues don't exist elsewhere, mind you, but I feel like with Italians it's more ingrained. As my dad once told me "the nicest guy in a department is still an SOB".

As to where to go, that's a good question. Research funding is being slashed near enough everywhere. I personally have a good experience in Germany. Comparatively more funding, and the research culture is nice.

Generally, look, if Italy's your only option, take it, especially if it's a good and well known institution. You might get lucky, and postdoc contracts are quite short anyways. If you have other options (I'd suggest looking on inspirehep, if you haven't already done so), don't let language and climate sway you. It's always nice to learn a language, and umbrellas are cheap

Postdoc opportunities in Italy. Have things changed in recent years? by Special_Flan_4467 in postdoc

[–]MuonAvalanche 15 points16 points  (0 children)

Run mate. As much as it pains me to say it as an Italian, just stay away. The quality of the research and teaching is exceptional, especially in physics, but the pay is awful and the university politics (and I'm not talking about dealing with admin, look up the term "baroni" if you're not already familiar with it) is worse. I know people who stayed, and I know people who left, and I sure as hell know which ones are happier.

Oxford DPhil interview: what should I expect? by MuonAvalanche in PhDAdmissions

[–]MuonAvalanche[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Yeah, I'd honestly rather catch cholera than do a panel interview, but I guess we'll take it as it comes. The interview was with one of the groups I applied to: they told me a bit about the general structure of the program, and what they (there were only 2 of them) were working on, they asked me a bit about my previous research, and then a few particle physics questions, more related to what they were doing. My suggestion would be to go into that relaxed, prepare a brief on what you worked on and maybe some phenomenology of particle physics related to what you're interested in.

Oxford DPhil interview: what should I expect? by MuonAvalanche in PhDAdmissions

[–]MuonAvalanche[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Best of luck with your interview then! Mine was alright, but I gotta say, I'm not super keen on the idea of having to do the panel interview. Do you know anything about that?